Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumThe New Negro Movement and Cultural Debates

Read the excerpt from a 1928 letter by writer Claude McKay, responding to critics of his novel Home to Harlem, and answer the question that follows:

'I have not written about the intellectual class because I do not know them as intimately... My main concern is to depict the life of the lower-class Negro as it is, without apology or sugar-coating. If this pleases those who want only "propaganda" of respectability, so be it... The colored intelligentsia cannot dictate what we should write. They want us to show only the polite, clean, and educated side of our people to please white America, but that is not the whole truth of our lives.'

Based on the excerpt, McKay's defense of his work most directly reflects which of the following debates within the New Negro Movement?

  1. A
    The political rivalry between advocates of vocational training and proponents of liberal arts education for the Talented Tenth
  2. B
    The dispute between proponents of grassroots economic nationalism and organizers of elite international Pan-African congresses
  3. The tension between depicting the raw realities of working-class Black life versus presenting polished, respectable images to counter white prejudiceAnswer
  4. D
    The legal and strategic disagreement over how to dismantle state-enforced segregation in the South compared to systemic housing discrimination in the North

Answer

The tension between depicting the raw realities of working-class Black life versus presenting polished, respectable images to counter white prejudice
The correct answer is correct because McKay's letter directly addresses the conflict between representing the authentic, unvarnished lives of working-class African Americans and the elite-driven desire to present highly polished, respectable images of Black life to appeal to white society. This central debate of the New Negro Movement pitted writers who favored realistic, class-conscious depictions against those who believed art should serve primarily as positive propaganda for racial uplift.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the provided excerpt to identify the author's primary concern.
The author expresses a dedication to representing working-class Black life realistically and rejects the demand for 'propaganda of respectability' from elite critics.
Understanding the core argument of the primary source is necessary to connect it to the broader historical context.
2
Relate this core concern to the major cultural debates of the New Negro Movement.
The debate between realistic representation of the working class (the folk) versus respectability politics (art as propaganda for racial uplift) is identified as the matching theme.
This step allows the selection of the correct option that matches McKay's literary philosophy.

Key Concept

The debate over the representation of the 'folk' and respectability politics in New Negro Movement literature.
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Rate this question

Topics

The New Negro Movement and Cultural Debates

More questions from this topic