Examkin

The New Negro Movement and Cultural Debates

34 questions

Question 1Question →

Read the following excerpt from Wallace Thurman’s satirical novel *Infants of the Spring* (1932) and answer the question that follows:

"Here we are, all of us, [...] trying to be 'Negro' writers, 'Negro' artists, instead of just writers and artists. We’re so self-conscious about our race that we can’t think of anything else. We are always trying to prove something, or show how different we are, or how much like the whites we are. We are so busy being Negroes that we forget to be artists."

Which of the following debates within the New Negro Movement is most directly reflected in the characters' critique in this excerpt?

Show answer & explanation

Answer: The conflict between individual artistic freedom and the collective demand for art to serve as a tool for racial uplift and representation

Answer

The conflict between individual artistic freedom and the collective demand for art to serve as a tool for racial uplift and representation
The correct answer is the option focusing on the conflict between individual artistic freedom and the collective demand for art to serve as a tool for racial uplift. The excerpt critiques the self-consciousness of Harlem Renaissance artists, arguing that the focus on race as a performance or political tool ('trying to prove something') limits genuine artistic expression. This direct critique aligns with the central debate of the era between writers who wanted absolute creative autonomy (like Langston Hughes and Wallace Thurman) and those who believed Black art should primarily serve to uplift the race and present a polished image to white society (like W.E.B. Du Bois).

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the provided text from Wallace Thurman's novel.
The characters express frustration with the 'self-conscious' pressure to be 'Negro' artists rather than just 'artists', criticizing the need to constantly 'prove something' or show similarity/difference to white society.
This establishes that the core issue is the conflict between individual creative autonomy and racial representation constraints.
2
Evaluate the options against the core critique identified in the text.
The option concerning the conflict between individual artistic freedom and the collective demand for racial uplift matches the critique exactly.
This identifies the correct option while distinguishing it from unrelated historical debates (education, emigrationism, and gender politics).

Key Concept

The aesthetic debate between individual artistic autonomy and racial uplift/propaganda in Harlem Renaissance literature.
Question 2Question →

Read the following excerpt from Zora Neale Hurston's essay 'Characteristics of Negro Expression' (1934):

'It has been pointed out by several writers that the Negro mime is not copyism, but is rather a reworking of the original. The Negro is a very creative mimic. His mimicry is a creative art. ... Thus, the jazz band takes syncopation, which is African, and applies it to the standard white tunes, and the result is something new. The Negro takes the white man's language, and makes of it a new thing. He takes the white man's religion, and changes its mood. In each case, there is a distinct and creative modification. This is not imitation; it is assimilation and transformation.'

Based on the excerpt, which of the following best describes how Hurston's analysis of mimicry contributes to the cultural debates of the New Negro Movement?

Show answer & explanation

Answer: It asserts that mimicry is an active, transformative process of reworking existing forms, thereby validating a distinct African American cultural identity that is neither purely derivative nor entirely separate from American culture.

Answer

The correct answer asserts that mimicry is an active, transformative process of reworking existing forms, validating a distinct African American cultural identity that is neither purely derivative nor entirely separate from American culture.
The correct answer is correct because Hurston highlights how African Americans do not simply copy white cultural elements (such as language, music, or religion) but instead modify and transform them to create entirely new cultural expressions. This perspective directly addresses the New Negro debates by presenting a model of cultural distinctiveness that is rooted in creative adaptation and synthesis rather than complete isolation or passive submission.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the source passage to identify Hurston's definition of mimicry.
Hurston defines mimicry as 'not copyism, but is rather a reworking of the original' and represents 'a distinct and creative modification.'
Understanding the author's specific definition of the key term is necessary to analyze its role in the broader debate.
2
Connect Hurston's argument to the cultural debates of the New Negro Movement.
Identify that the debate centers on the tension between cultural assimilation (subservience to white norms) and cultural distinctiveness (expressing a unique African American identity).
This establishes the historical context needed to evaluate the options.
3
Evaluate the options to see which matches Hurston's model of cultural synthesis.
The option stating that mimicry is an active, transformative process fits Hurston's stance that adaptation results in 'something new' and constitutes 'assimilation and transformation.'
This identifies the correct conceptual link between the passage and the movement's debates.
4
Eliminate distractors that misrepresent the political and historical positions of other contemporary movements.
Eliminate options linking Hurston's aesthetics to Marcus Garvey's political separatism, Booker T. Washington's accommodationism, or a static view of pre-colonial African traditions.
This ensures the selected option is correct and free of historical conflations.

Key Concept

The New Negro Movement and Cultural Debates
Question 3Question →

Read the following excerpt from Zora Neale Hurston's essay 'Characteristics of Negro Expression' (1934) and answer the question that follows.

'The Negro's universal mimicry is not [a] sign of a lack of originality as the detractors believe, but is rather an evidence of his power of absorption and modification. Characters, dances, and songs, once encountered, are immediately lived. The Negro has conformed the foreign tongue to his acoustic needs. He has made over a great part of the tongue so that we have "negroized" English... The will to adorn is the second most notable characteristic of Negro expression.'

Which of the following debates within the New Negro Movement is most directly illustrated by Hurston's arguments in the excerpt?

Show answer & explanation

Answer: The debate over whether African American artists should create a distinct aesthetic based on folk culture or conform to Western literary and artistic traditions.

Answer

The debate over whether African American artists should create a distinct aesthetic based on folk culture or conform to Western literary and artistic traditions.
The correct answer is correct because Hurston highlights the unique, creative ways in which African Americans modified the English language and cultural forms (like dances and songs). This perspective validates Black vernacular and folk culture as a legitimate source of art, representing the side of the debate that embraced distinct African American folk traditions rather than conforming to Eurocentric high-art standards.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the passage to identify the central focus.
The passage focus is on Zora Neale Hurston defending Black cultural modification, linguistic adaptation, and the unique artistic value of vernacular expression (the 'will to adorn').
Understanding the core argument of the excerpt is necessary to connect it to historical debates.
2
Relate the passage's themes to known intellectual debates of the New Negro Movement.
Hurston's validation of folk expressions directly corresponds to the debate over whether Black artists should embrace distinct cultural traditions or conform to established Eurocentric standards to demonstrate intellectual capability.
Connecting the specific text to broader curriculum concepts allows identification of the correct historical debate.

Key Concept

The New Negro Movement and Cultural Debates
Question 4Question →

Read the following excerpt from Alain Locke’s essay "The New Negro" (1925):

"Up to the present, American Negroes have been a race more in name than in fact, or to be exact, more in collective destiny than in collective consciousness. The pressure of the common trial rather than the cohesion of the common forward impulse has made and kept them together. But the thinking Negro has slipped from under the tyranny of social status and our leaders are today launching a new movement of self-determination."

According to Locke, which of the following best describes the transition in identity represented by the "New Negro"?

Show answer & explanation

Answer: A shift from an identity defined by external oppression and social status to one rooted in self-determination and collective consciousness

Answer

A shift from an identity defined by external oppression and social status to one rooted in self-determination and collective consciousness
The correct answer accurately interprets Locke's distinction between a passive group identity formed by external trials and a proactive group consciousness driven by internal cohesion and cultural self-determination.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the provided excerpt from Alain Locke's 'The New Negro'.
Identify that Locke distinguishes between being kept together by 'the pressure of the common trial' (shared oppression) versus the 'cohesion of the common forward impulse' (self-determination).
This establishes the core transition Locke is describing.
2
Evaluate the choices to find the one that accurately summarizes this transition.
The option stating that identity shifts from external oppression to self-determination and collective consciousness matches Locke's emphasis on slipping 'from under the tyranny of social status' and launching a 'new movement of self-determination.'
This confirms the correct option based on the text.

Key Concept

The New Negro Movement and Cultural Debates
Question 5Question →

In his autobiography, *The Big Sea*, Langston Hughes reflects on his relationship with a wealthy white patron:

> '[She] wanted me to be primitive and know and feel the intuitions of the wild, untamed, unsatisfied surges of Negro blood. She did not want me to write about northern cities, or working people, or the problems of the industrial South. She wanted me to be a child of nature, and write from the heart, not from the mind.'

Which central cultural debate of the New Negro Movement is most directly reflected in this conflict?

Show answer & explanation

Answer: The struggle between the expectations of white patrons who sought romanticized, 'exotic' portrayals of Black life and Black artists' demands for genuine creative autonomy.

Answer

The struggle between the expectations of white patrons who sought romanticized, 'exotic' portrayals of Black life and Black artists' demands for genuine creative autonomy.
The correct answer is correct because the excerpt illustrates the conflict between white patrons (such as Charlotte Osgood Mason, whom Hughes referred to as 'Godmother') who funded Harlem Renaissance artists under the condition that they depict a romanticized, 'primitive' African American culture, and the artists themselves (like Hughes) who wanted to write realistically about contemporary working-class life, northern urban experiences, and social struggles. This tension between patronage and self-determination was a central debate of the New Negro Movement.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the provided source text for key themes.
The author (Langston Hughes) describes a patron who wanted him to write about 'primitive' themes ('wild, untamed, unsatisfied surges of Negro blood') and specifically prohibited him from writing about modern, realistic experiences ('northern cities, or working people, or the problems of the industrial South').
To understand the core conflict or tension being described in the autobiography excerpt.
2
Connect the identified conflict to historical debates of the Harlem Renaissance/New Negro Movement.
The conflict directly represents the tension between the financial patronage of white philanthropists, who often held exoticizing or paternalistic expectations for Black art, and Black writers' struggle for self-determination and realistic representation of Black life.
To identify which option accurately captures this cultural and historical debate.

Key Concept

The New Negro Movement and Cultural Debates (specifically, the tension between white patronage and artistic autonomy)
Question 6Question →

In his 1926 essay 'Criteria of Negro Art,' W.E.B. Du Bois wrote:

'Thus all Art is propaganda and ever must be, despite the wailing of the purists. I stand in utter shamelessness and say that whatever art I have for writing has been used always for propaganda for gaining the right of black folk to love and enjoy.'

Which of the following best summarizes Du Bois's argument in this excerpt?

Show answer & explanation

Answer: African American art and literature should be consciously used to promote racial advancement and civil rights.

Answer

The correct answer is that African American art and literature should be consciously used to promote racial advancement and civil rights.
The correct option is that African American art and literature should be consciously used to promote racial advancement and civil rights. In the excerpt, Du Bois explicitly defines art as 'propaganda' aimed at securing rights and enjoyment for Black people, directly linking creative expression with political and social activism.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the primary source excerpt for Du Bois's main claim about art.
Du Bois states that 'all Art is propaganda' and that his own writing is used for the advancement of Black people's rights.
To identify the central thesis of the author's argument regarding the role of Black art.
2
Compare the main claim to the provided choices to find the closest match.
The statement that art should promote racial advancement and civil rights aligns directly with Du Bois's definition of art as propaganda for Black rights.
To select the correct option that accurately summarizes the excerpt.

Key Concept

The debate over the social and political purpose of art during the New Negro Movement.
Question 7Question →

Read the excerpt below from W.E.B. Du Bois's 1928 review of Claude McKay's novel *Home to Harlem* in *The Crisis* magazine and answer the question that follows.

"[The novel] for the most part nauseates me, and after the dirtier parts of its filth I feel distinctly like taking a bath... [The author] has set out to cater to that craving of the white public for the 'nigger-heaven' type of book. He has used every art of description to make it seem that the Harlem Negro is nothing but a creature of raw lust, animalism, and lack of restraint."

Which of the following central debates of the New Negro Movement does Du Bois's critique best illustrate?

Show answer & explanation

Answer: The tension between older leaders who argued that art must serve as political advocacy to showcase Black respectability, and younger creators who demanded the freedom to portray working-class realities.

Answer

The tension between older leaders who argued that art must serve as political advocacy to showcase Black respectability, and younger creators who demanded the freedom to portray working-class realities.
The correct answer is correct because W.E.B. Du Bois's critique of Claude McKay's *Home to Harlem* epitomizes the generational and philosophical debate of the Harlem Renaissance regarding the function of Black art. Du Bois and other older leaders believed that art should serve as political propaganda to combat white racism by displaying middle-class respectability. Conversely, younger writers like Claude McKay, Langston Hughes, and Zora Neale Hurston believed that artists should be free to portray all aspects of Black life, including working-class culture and vernacular experiences, without being constrained by the politics of respectability.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the primary source excerpt to identify the author, source context, and core argument.
The author is W.E.B. Du Bois, writing in *The Crisis* in 1928, criticizing a novel for portraying Black characters as having 'lack of restraint' and accusing the author of catering to white stereotypes.
This establishes that the conflict is about representation, audience, and the purpose of literature during the Harlem Renaissance.
2
Relate Du Bois's critique to the larger cultural debates of the New Negro Movement.
Du Bois's critique represents the 'art as propaganda' perspective, which believed that creative works should elevate the race and fight prejudice by presenting respectable images of Black life, whereas younger writers favored realistic depictions of the working class and folk culture.
This matches the core debate between lockstep respectability and artistic freedom in the 1920s.
3
Evaluate the choices to find the one that accurately describes this tension and identify the errors in the distractors.
The option detailing the tension between older leaders advocating for respectability and younger creators seeking working-class representation is correct. The other choices misattribute the debate to education, political nationalism, or emigrationism.
This confirms the correct option while eliminating the distractors based on established historical debates.

Key Concept

The New Negro Movement and Cultural Debates
Question 8Question →

In the 1922 preface to *The Book of American Negro Poetry*, James Weldon Johnson wrote:

> "The Negro poet in the United States is finding that the standard Negro dialect is an instrument with but two full stops, humor and pathos. [...] He needs to find a form of expression that has a local color, a Negro flavor, but which is also capable of voicing the deepest and highest emotions and aspirations, and allowing of the widest range of subjects. He needs a form of expression that is larger than dialect and which will still have its power."

Based on this excerpt, which of the following debates within the New Negro Movement is most directly reflected in Johnson's argument?

Show answer & explanation

Answer: The struggle to create a unique literary aesthetic that reflects authentic Black cultural experiences without relying on racial stereotypes or caricatured folk forms.

Answer

The struggle to create a unique literary aesthetic that reflects authentic Black cultural experiences without relying on racial stereotypes or caricatured folk forms.
The correct answer is correct because James Weldon Johnson is arguing that traditional dialect poetry is too narrow and caricatured (limited to 'humor and pathos' by historical minstrel conventions). He advocates for a new literary aesthetic that retains cultural authenticity ('local color, a Negro flavor') but is capable of a wider, more complex emotional range. This represents a central debate of the New Negro Movement: how to represent Black identity in art without succumbing to white-imposed stereotypes.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the provided excerpt from James Weldon Johnson's 1922 preface.
Identify that Johnson is criticizing 'standard Negro dialect' as having 'but two full stops, humor and pathos' and is calling for a new 'form of expression' with a 'Negro flavor' that can voice 'deepest and highest emotions.'
Understanding the core argument is necessary to connect it to the broader cultural debates of the era.
2
Evaluate the choices to see which debate aligns with Johnson's critique of dialect and his call for a new artistic form.
Recognize that the correct option directly addresses the tension between using traditional, sometimes caricatured folk forms (dialect) and developing a sophisticated literary aesthetic that retains cultural authenticity.
This matches Johnson's call for a form of expression that is 'larger than dialect' while still retaining its cultural 'power.'

Key Concept

The Harlem Renaissance/New Negro Movement cultural debates over representation, dialect, and the development of a distinct African American literary aesthetic.
Question 9Question →

Read the excerpt below from a 1927 essay by scholar Benjamin Brawley and answer the question that follows:

"It is in the choice of themes that the new school is most vulnerable. It seems to have gone wild over the 'low-down' Negro... in the effort to be 'different' or to be 'realistic' it has too often mistaken the sordid for the significant, and the vulgar for the vital. We have a right to expect of our writers and artists something more than a preoccupation with the cabaret and the dive..."

Which of the following debates within the New Negro Movement is best illustrated by Brawley's critique?

Show answer & explanation

Answer: The division between established Black intellectuals who advocated for art as a tool of moral respectability and racial uplift, and younger artists who demanded the freedom to depict working-class realism.

Answer

The division between established Black intellectuals who advocated for art as a tool of moral respectability and racial uplift, and younger artists who demanded the freedom to depict working-class realism.
The correct answer accurately identifies the tension between the older generation's advocacy for respectability politics and the younger generation's pursuit of artistic realism. Benjamin Brawley, representing conservative Black intellectuals, argued that literature should uplift the race by highlighting middle-class refinements and moral standards. Conversely, younger Harlem Renaissance writers like Langston Hughes and Zora Neale Hurston believed that authentic art must represent the real, raw experiences of the Black working class.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the stimulus excerpt to identify the author's core critique.
The author (Benjamin Brawley) objects to the 'new school' of writers depicting 'low-down' themes, 'cabarets,' and what he considers 'sordid' and 'vulgar' aspects of life.
Identifying the author's primary argument is necessary to map it to the correct historical debate.
2
Relate Brawley's argument to the cultural debates of the New Negro Movement.
Brawley's demand that writers focus on 'something more' than these gritty themes reflects the older generation's belief in respectability politics and art as a tool for racial uplift, which conflicted with the younger writers' desire for realistic representations of Black working-class culture.
This step connects the primary source to the target learning objective regarding the Harlem Renaissance's internal debates.
3
Evaluate the options to find the one that accurately describes this tension.
The option identifying the conflict between moral respectability and working-class realism is selected as the correct answer.
This option captures the exact aesthetic and ideological divide illustrated in the passage, whereas other choices focus on unrelated political, educational, or socioeconomic disputes.

Key Concept

The New Negro Movement and Cultural Debates
Question 10Question →

During the 1920s, the Harlem Renaissance ushered in a cultural movement often defined by the concept of the "New Negro," popularized by scholar Alain Locke. Which of the following best describes the primary characteristic that distinguished the "New Negro" from the "Old Negro"?

Show answer & explanation

Answer: A spirit of self-determination, racial pride, and active cultural self-expression

Answer

A spirit of self-determination, racial pride, and active cultural self-expression
The correct answer is correct because the 'New Negro' represented an intellectual and cultural shift toward self-determination, racial pride, and active artistic self-expression. Alain Locke's 1925 anthology emphasized that Black Americans were no longer passive subjects of social debates but active agents defining their own identity and heritage.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the historical context and meaning of the 'New Negro' as popularized by Alain Locke in 1925.
The term represents a psychological and cultural shift away from subservience and towards self-advocacy and artistic expression.
Knowing this distinction allows for the identification of the correct core characteristic of the movement.
2
Compare this concept to the strategies of earlier eras and alternative movements.
The 'Old Negro' was characterized by accommodation or being the passive object of debate, whereas the 'New Negro' actively shaped Black identity through literature, art, and intellectual discourse.
This confirms that the correct choice represents self-determination and cultural self-expression, distinguishing it from vocational accommodation or migration.

Key Concept

The shift from the accommodationist or passive representation of Black Americans to the self-determining, culturally expressive identity of the New Negro.
Question 11Question →

Read the following excerpt from the preface to Jessie Redmon Fauset's novel *The Chinaberry Tree* (1931) and answer the question that follows:

"But of the great transition class, the refining, developing, and expanding class of Negroes who live, move, and have their being in a world of their own, we hear almost nothing... It is of this class that I write."

Based on the excerpt and your knowledge of the New Negro Movement, Fauset's literary philosophy most directly aligns with which of the following positions in the cultural debates of the era?

Show answer & explanation

Answer: The belief that African American literature should focus on depicting respectable, middle-class lives to counter racial prejudice and argue for social equality.

Answer

The belief that African American literature should focus on depicting respectable, middle-class lives to counter racial prejudice and argue for social equality.
The correct answer is correct because Jessie Redmon Fauset, along with other editors and writers of the older generation during the Harlem Renaissance, believed in the politics of respectability. She argued that portraying educated, refined, and moral middle-class African American characters would challenge white supremacy and demonstrate that Black Americans were deserving of equal social and political rights.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the provided excerpt to identify the author's target subjects.
The excerpt focuses on 'the great transition class, the refining, developing, and expanding class of Negroes' (the Black middle class) rather than marginalized or lower-class characters.
Understanding the author's chosen subject matter is necessary to connect it to the broader debates of the Harlem Renaissance.
2
Relate this focus to the core cultural debates of the New Negro Movement.
Fauset's focus on depicting the middle class represents the 'politics of respectability' and 'uplift' literature, which aimed to combat racial prejudice by showing the refinement of Black lives.
This aligns with the correct option that highlights the role of literature in countering stereotypes and promoting equality.

Key Concept

The New Negro Movement and Cultural Debates
Question 12Question →

Read the excerpt from a 1928 letter by writer Claude McKay, responding to critics of his novel Home to Harlem, and answer the question that follows:

'I have not written about the intellectual class because I do not know them as intimately... My main concern is to depict the life of the lower-class Negro as it is, without apology or sugar-coating. If this pleases those who want only "propaganda" of respectability, so be it... The colored intelligentsia cannot dictate what we should write. They want us to show only the polite, clean, and educated side of our people to please white America, but that is not the whole truth of our lives.'

Based on the excerpt, McKay's defense of his work most directly reflects which of the following debates within the New Negro Movement?

Show answer & explanation

Answer: The tension between depicting the raw realities of working-class Black life versus presenting polished, respectable images to counter white prejudice

Answer

The tension between depicting the raw realities of working-class Black life versus presenting polished, respectable images to counter white prejudice
The correct answer is correct because McKay's letter directly addresses the conflict between representing the authentic, unvarnished lives of working-class African Americans and the elite-driven desire to present highly polished, respectable images of Black life to appeal to white society. This central debate of the New Negro Movement pitted writers who favored realistic, class-conscious depictions against those who believed art should serve primarily as positive propaganda for racial uplift.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the provided excerpt to identify the author's primary concern.
The author expresses a dedication to representing working-class Black life realistically and rejects the demand for 'propaganda of respectability' from elite critics.
Understanding the core argument of the primary source is necessary to connect it to the broader historical context.
2
Relate this core concern to the major cultural debates of the New Negro Movement.
The debate between realistic representation of the working class (the folk) versus respectability politics (art as propaganda for racial uplift) is identified as the matching theme.
This step allows the selection of the correct option that matches McKay's literary philosophy.

Key Concept

The debate over the representation of the 'folk' and respectability politics in New Negro Movement literature.
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Question 13Question →

In his landmark 1925 anthology *The New Negro*, Alain Locke describes a shift in African American consciousness, writing that the "Negro has been more of a formula than a human being" but is now "shaking off the psychology of imitation and dependency." According to Locke, what is the defining characteristic of the "New Negro"?

Show answer & explanation

Answer: A commitment to self-determination, self-reliance, and pride in African American cultural and artistic expression

Answer

A commitment to self-determination, self-reliance, and pride in African American cultural and artistic expression
Alain Locke defined the 'New Negro' as an active, self-reliant participant in American society who used literature, art, and intellectual debate to express pride and demand respect, representing a psychological shift away from dependency and subordination.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the quote and Locke's definition of the 'New Negro'.
The New Negro is defined by moving away from dependency, imitation, and being treated as a passive social 'formula' toward self-reliance.
Locke stresses that the New Negro has gained self-respect and self-reliance, expressing this transformation through art, literature, and social consciousness.
2
Evaluate the options to identify which one aligns with this cultural and psychological shift.
The option emphasizing self-determination, self-reliance, and cultural pride directly matches Locke's definition.
This option captures the shift from dependency to active self-expression and self-determination.

Key Concept

The New Negro Movement and Cultural Debates
Estimated Time:45s
Question 14Question →

During the Harlem Renaissance and the New Negro Movement of the 1920s, a significant debate emerged among Black writers and intellectuals regarding the role of creative works. Which of the following best summarizes the central question of this cultural debate?

Show answer & explanation

Answer: Should African American art and literature serve primarily as political tools for civil rights, or should they focus on individual creative self-expression?

Answer

Should African American art and literature serve primarily as political tools for civil rights, or should they focus on individual creative self-expression?
The correct option identifies the primary aesthetic and political tension of the Harlem Renaissance. Intellectuals like W.E.B. Du Bois argued in 'Criteria of Negro Art' that all art must serve a political purpose to combat racism, while younger writers like Langston Hughes and editors like Alain Locke advocated for the freedom of Black artists to express themselves without being constrained by political demands or respectability politics.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the historical context and central theme of the question.
The question asks about the primary cultural debate during the New Negro Movement and Harlem Renaissance of the 1920s.
Understanding the timeline and key cultural questions of the 1920s allows the student to distinguish between artistic debates and political/educational ones.
2
Evaluate the choices against the central intellectual tensions of the Harlem Renaissance.
The major tension was between using art as political 'propaganda' for racial advancement (Du Bois) versus pursuing pure artistic freedom and self-determination (Locke, Hughes).
This directly matches the choice discussing the role of art as a political tool versus a medium for self-expression, whereas other choices refer to different historical eras or debates (like education or emigration).

Key Concept

The debate over the role of art and literature in political struggle versus individual self-expression during the New Negro Movement.
Question 15Question →

Read the excerpt from Wallace Thurman’s novel *Infants of the Spring* (1932) and answer the question that follows.

"We are all, writers, painters, poets, and sculptors, showcase exhibits... The younger generation is in revolt, but it is a revolt without a program. We have rebelled against the paternalism of our elders, who insisted that every book or painting must be a document of racial uplift. Yet in doing so, we have fallen into the trap of satisfying the white fad for the exotic and the primitive."

Based on the excerpt, which of the following best describes the central tension Thurman identifies within the New Negro Movement?

Show answer & explanation

Answer: The pressure on Black artists to choose between producing art for moral respectability as dictated by the Black elite, and catering to the exoticized expectations of white patrons.

Answer

The pressure on Black artists to choose between producing art for moral respectability as dictated by the Black elite, and catering to the exoticized expectations of white patrons.
The correct option accurately identifies the dual constraints placed on Harlem Renaissance artists as outlined by Thurman: the internal pressure from the older Black middle-class leadership ('our elders') who wanted art to serve as respectable propaganda for racial uplift, and the external pressure from white patrons who sought to consume exotic and primitive depictions of Black life.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the stimulus passage for the core forces and agents acting upon young Black artists.
The passage identifies two major constraints: the paternalism of Black 'elders' demanding 'racial uplift' and the demands of 'white patrons' seeking 'the exotic and the primitive.'
This establishes the parameters of the central conflict described by the author.
2
Evaluate the options to find the one that accurately synthesizes these two opposing forces.
The option concerning the pressure of moral respectability from the Black elite versus exoticized expectations from white patrons matches the identified forces.
This directly maps the passage's textual details onto the historical concepts of the Harlem Renaissance cultural debates.

Key Concept

The conflict between artistic independence, respectability politics, and white patronage during the Harlem Renaissance.
Estimated Time:2m 0s
Question 16Question →

Read the excerpt from George S. Schuyler's 1926 essay 'Negro-Art Hokum' and answer the question that follows:

"Aside from his color, which ranging from very dark brown to pinkish white has no influence on his mentalities and outlook, the American Negro is just plain American... As a class, the Negroes of the United States are as different from the African Negroes as two groups of humans can be. The American Negro writer, painter, and sculptor are subject to the same influences as their white fellow citizens, and their work is as American as their speech."

Which of the following contemporary perspectives directly challenged Schuyler’s argument by asserting that Black artists should focus on expressing their distinct racial and cultural heritage?

Show answer & explanation

Answer: Langston Hughes's defense of artistic freedom, which argued that Black artists must express their unique experiences and heritage without shame or the desire to conform to white standards.

Answer

Langston Hughes's defense of artistic freedom, which argued that Black artists must express their unique experiences and heritage without shame or the desire to conform to white standards.
The correct option is the one describing Langston Hughes's perspective. In 'The Negro Artist and the Racial Mountain' (1926), Hughes explicitly argued that Black artists must resist the urge to assimilate into white aesthetic standards, declaring that they should express their individual and racial selves with pride and without fear or shame.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the provided excerpt from George S. Schuyler's 'Negro-Art Hokum'.
Identify Schuyler's core argument: that there is no distinct 'Negro art' because African Americans are fully assimilated into American culture and subject to the same environmental influences as white Americans.
Understanding the source material is necessary to find the perspective that directly opposes it.
2
Evaluate the contemporary arguments of the Harlem Renaissance that challenged Schuyler's assimilationist viewpoint.
Identify Langston Hughes's 'The Negro Artist and the Racial Mountain' (1926) as the direct counter-argument, which championed the creation of distinct Black art as an expression of racial pride and self-determination.
This matches the prompt's request for the perspective that challenged Schuyler by advocating for a distinct racial and cultural artistic expression.

Key Concept

The Harlem Renaissance debate over assimilation versus racial distinctiveness in Black art and literature.
Question 17Question →

Read the excerpt from the preface to *The Book of American Negro Poetry* (1922), written by writer and activist James Weldon Johnson, and answer the question that follows:

"What the colored poet in the United States needs to do is something like what Synge did for the Irish; he needs to find a form that will express the racial spirit by symbols from within rather than by symbols from without, and which will be freed from the limitations of Negro dialect as a medium, especially the limitations that practically cut off all emotions but humor and pathos."

Which of the following statements best describes the primary challenge for African American artists identified by Johnson in the excerpt?

Show answer & explanation

Answer: Developing original literary forms that convey the full emotional range of Black life without relying on the restrictive conventions of traditional dialect writing.

Answer

Developing original literary forms that convey the full emotional range of Black life without relying on the restrictive conventions of traditional dialect writing.
The correct answer is correct because James Weldon Johnson argues that Black poets must find new artistic forms that can express their inner experiences and 'racial spirit' without being restricted by the conventions of dialect, which historically limited expression to superficial humor and pathos.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the provided excerpt from James Weldon Johnson's preface.
Identify that Johnson is concerned with how Black poets express the 'racial spirit' and his critique of 'Negro dialect' as a limiting medium that reduces expression to 'humor and pathos'.
This establishes the core argument of the passage, which focuses on the artistic and structural limitations of existing literary forms.
2
Evaluate the choices to find the one that matches Johnson's call for artistic innovation.
The correct choice must capture the idea of moving beyond dialect to express the full depth of Black humanity from within, which corresponds to the choice about developing original literary forms to convey the full emotional range of Black life.
This connects the textual analysis directly to the correct answer choice.

Key Concept

The New Negro Movement and Cultural Debates
Question 18Question →

Read the excerpt from W. E. B. Du Bois's essay 'Criteria of Negro Art' (1926) and answer the question that follows:

'Thus all Art is propaganda and ever must be, despite the wailing of the purists. I stand in utter shamelessness and say that whatever art I have for writing has been used always for propaganda for gaining the right of black folk to love and enjoy. I do not care a damn for any art that is not used for propaganda.'

Which of the following best describes the primary disagreement between W. E. B. Du Bois's artistic philosophy and that of many younger Harlem Renaissance writers, such as Langston Hughes?

Show answer & explanation

Answer: Du Bois believed art must actively serve the political goal of racial advancement, whereas the younger writers argued that art should reflect authentic, uncensored personal and cultural expression.

Answer

Du Bois believed art must actively serve the political goal of racial advancement, whereas the younger writers argued that art should reflect authentic, uncensored personal and cultural expression.
The correct answer accurately captures the tension between W. E. B. Du Bois's belief that all art must serve a political purpose to combat racism and secure civil rights, and the younger generation of Harlem Renaissance artists—such as Langston Hughes—who rejected the burden of respectability politics and argued for the freedom to depict Black life in all its complexity, including its working-class and folk elements.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze Du Bois's argument in the provided excerpt.
Du Bois explicitly claims that 'all Art is propaganda' and that he uses his writing to advocate for the rights of Black people, showing he believes art must have a political and social purpose.
This establishes Du Bois's position in the cultural debate of the period.
2
Contrast Du Bois's views with those of younger Harlem Renaissance writers like Langston Hughes.
Younger writers defended their right to portray working-class Black life and individual experiences without feeling pressured to conform to political propaganda or middle-class respectability.
This identifies the counterpoint in the debate.
3
Select the option that correctly represents this divergence of philosophies.
The option contrasting art as a tool for political advancement with art as authentic, uncensored personal expression is the correct choice.
It accurately reflects both sides of the historical debate.

Key Concept

The New Negro Movement and Cultural Debates
Question 19Question →

Read the excerpt from Langston Hughes's autobiography *The Big Sea* (1940) and answer the question that follows.

"She wanted me to be primitive, and know and feel the intuitions of the primitive. But, unfortunately, I was not Africa. I was Chicago and Kansas City and Broadway and Harlem. And I was not what she wanted me to be."

Based on the excerpt, which of the following best describes the cultural debate or tension that Hughes is addressing?

Show answer & explanation

Answer: The conflict between satisfying the exoticized expectations of white patrons and asserting authentic, modern Black identities

Answer

The conflict between satisfying the exoticized expectations of white patrons and asserting authentic, modern Black identities
The correct answer is correct because Hughes's reflection on his patron's desire for him to be 'primitive' illustrates the widespread pressure exerted by white patrons on Black artists to conform to essentialist and exoticized stereotypes. By contrast, Hughes asserts that his authentic identity was shaped by modern, urban American environments like Chicago, Kansas City, and Harlem, highlighting the struggle for creative autonomy during the New Negro Movement.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the source text to identify the subject of Langston Hughes's conflict.
Hughes describes a patron ("She") who wanted him to be "primitive" and represent "Africa" rather than his actual modern urban experiences in Chicago, Kansas City, and Harlem.
Identifying the core subject of the quote is necessary to understand the specific debate being addressed.
2
Relate the conflict to the broader cultural debates of the New Negro Movement.
The tension between white patronage (which often sought exoticism or primitivism) and the artist's desire for authentic self-expression was a major cultural debate.
Connecting the text to the historical context allows for selection of the correct interpretive statement.

Key Concept

The conflict between white patronage expectations and artistic autonomy during the Harlem Renaissance.
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Question 20Question →

Read the following review of Claude McKay’s novel *Home to Harlem* (1928), written by W. E. B. Du Bois and published in *The Crisis*:

> "[The novel] for the most part caters to that grosser demand on the part of white readers for license and sensuality... it looks as though McKay has tried to write something that would sell, rather than something that represents the deep, true soul of Negro life."

Which of the following debates from the New Negro Movement is best represented by the critique in the excerpt?

Show answer & explanation

Answer: The conflict over whether Black literature should focus on positive, middle-class representations for racial uplift or depict working-class life with raw realism.

Answer

The conflict over whether Black literature should focus on positive, middle-class representations for racial uplift or depict working-class life with raw realism.
The correct answer is the conflict over whether Black literature should focus on positive, middle-class representations for racial uplift or depict working-class life with raw realism. W. E. B. Du Bois's critique of Claude McKay's *Home to Harlem* encapsulates the Harlem Renaissance debate between respectability politics and artistic freedom. Intellectuals like Du Bois argued that art should act as propaganda to uplift the race by showing moral, educated, and middle-class Black figures. In contrast, writers like McKay and Langston Hughes believed that true artistic expression required representing working-class African American life honestly, including its joys, struggles, and vernacular, without censoring elements to please white or elite Black critics.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the tone and subject of the review of Claude McKay’s novel in the excerpt.
The reviewer critiques the depiction of 'license and sensuality' for white audiences and argues it fails to represent the 'true soul' of Black life.
This establishes that the author of the critique believes art has a moral duty to present a respectable and 'true' image of the race rather than appealing to popular tastes or raw realism.
2
Connect this critique to the core aesthetic conflicts of the Harlem Renaissance.
The conflict is identified as the debate over respectability politics (portraying middle-class achievement to combat prejudice) versus artistic realism (representing all strata of Black life, including the working class, without censorship).
This links the specific primary source critique directly to the broader cultural debates surrounding the New Negro Movement.

Key Concept

The debate over respectability politics and the purpose of art (racial uplift vs. artistic freedom) during the New Negro Movement.
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Page 1 / 2Next