Question

Difficulty: MediumNarrator Reliability, Perspective, and Bias

Read the following passage carefully:

(1) Mr. Finch’s garden was a public scandal, though he called it a sanctuary.
(2) Where a proper lawn of neatly clipped rye should have mirrored the order of
(3) our respectable street, he permitted a wild tangle of chicory, dandelion,
(4) and unkept lavender to overflow the cracked stone flags of his walk.
(5) Day after day, he would stand among his weeds, wearing that faded tweed cap
(6) that had surely seen better decades, offering pocketfuls of bruised plums to
(7) the neighborhood children who passed his gate. He claimed, with that familiar
(8) and rather tiresome theatricality of his, that the plums were "nature’s own
(9) confections," but one could see they were merely the surplus of an untended
(10) tree he was too indolent to prune. My own children were strictly forbidden
(11) from accepting his offerings; there was something intensely calculating in
(12) the way he sought their smiles, as if trying to purchase the affection of a
(13) neighborhood that had long since seen through his eccentric performance.
(14) When the winter frost finally laid bare the ruins of his flowerbeds, he simply
(15) retreated inside, leaving the dry stalks to rattle in the wind—a stubborn,
(16) silent testament to his failure to contribute anything of value to our little
(17) community.

Which of the following best describes how the narrator's bias shapes her portrayal of Mr. Finch in the passage?

  1. A
    literal understanding of the overgrown garden as a sign of Mr. Finch's poverty rather than a rejection of community norms
  2. B
    concern with detailing the timeline of how the garden deteriorated from summer to winter
  3. preoccupation with social propriety, which causes the narrator to view acts of simple goodwill with suspicionAnswer
  4. D
    objective reporting of Mr. Finch’s manipulative nature and his refusal to maintain neighborhood standards
  5. E
    role as the author's voice in condemning the community's rigid insistence on suburban conformity

Answer

The correct answer states that the narrator's preoccupation with social propriety causes the narrator to view acts of simple goodwill with suspicion.
The correct answer identifies that the narrator’s rigid devotion to social propriety and neighborhood standards makes her suspicious of Mr. Finch's eccentric habits. Her bias leads her to interpret his generous offer of plums as a calculated attempt to buy affection, rather than a simple act of goodwill.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the narrator's descriptions of Mr. Finch and his garden, noting the contrast between his actions (offering plums, keeping a natural garden) and her negative characterizations ('scandal', 'indolent', 'calculating').
Identify that the narrator views Mr. Finch through a lens of judgment, viewing his non-conformity as a moral and social failure.
Establishing the narrator's tone and values is necessary to evaluate her reliability and bias.
2
Evaluate the narrator's specific interpretation of Mr. Finch's gift of plums to the children in lines 7–13.
Observe that she attributes a cynical motive to his actions ('intensely calculating', 'trying to purchase... affection') despite no evidence of harm.
This step reveals the direct manifestation of her bias, where she reframes a benign act of sharing surplus fruit as manipulative.
3
Select the option that best captures how this bias limits the narrator's perspective.
The option describing her preoccupation with social propriety causing her to view goodwill with suspicion aligns perfectly with the textual evidence.
This option explains how the narrator's insistence on social decorum dictates her hostile interpretation of Mr. Finch's character.

Key Concept

Unreliable Narrator and Perspective Bias
Estimated Time:2m 0s
Rate this question