Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumNarrator Reliability, Perspective, and Bias

Read the following passage carefully:

(1) Arthur returned from his travels with a trunk full of nothing but pressed ferns and notebooks,
(2) a collection he guarded with a vigilance that seemed altogether disproportionate to its worth.
(3) He spent his afternoons in the drawing room, sitting by the window in silence, rarely offering
(4) a word unless directly addressed. To the rest of the household, this reticence was taken as
(5) a mark of profound contemplation, but I knew better; it was the hollow stillness of a mind
(6) that had run out of thoughts. Whenever I attempted to engage him in a discussion of the local
(7) parish council or the fluctuations of the timber market—matters of genuine consequence—he
(8) would merely smile, his gaze drifting back to the lawn as if he were too fragile to bear the
(9) weight of practical life. He was, I concluded, utterly defeated by the world, retreat being his
(10) only defense. Yet, my mother insisted on treating him as some sort of convalescent genius,
(11) preparing his tea herself and speaking in hushed tones, as though his lack of industry were
(12) a rare and delicate virtue rather than a simple failure of character.

Which of the following best describes how the narrator's perspective shapes the portrayal of Arthur in the passage?

  1. A
    Arthur's persistent silence and lack of interest in practical affairs prove that he is indeed intellectually defeated by the world.
  2. B
    The author uses Arthur's silence to criticize the empty materialism and social structures of the local parish.
  3. The narrator's rigid standard of utility leads him to interpret Arthur’s quiet reflection as a sign of intellectual vacancy.Answer
  4. D
    Arthur returns home with notebooks and ferns, spends his days by the window, and refuses to speak about the timber market.
  5. E
    The mother's indulgent behavior confirms that Arthur is suffering from a severe convalescent illness.

Answer

The narrator's rigid standard of utility leads him to interpret Arthur’s quiet reflection as a sign of intellectual vacancy.
The correct answer is correct because the narrator's perspective is defined by a narrow, utilitarian world view. He measures worth by active engagement in business and local administration. Because Arthur chooses to spend his time quietly reflecting and collecting ferns, the narrator dismisses this quietness as intellectual emptiness and a failure of character, showing how the narrator's bias directly shapes the portrayal of Arthur.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the narrator's own values and focus areas in the passage.
The narrator values practical, civic, and economic matters, calling the parish council and timber market 'matters of genuine consequence.'
This establishes the narrator's frame of reference and potential source of bias.
2
Examine how the narrator evaluates Arthur's behavior through this frame of reference.
Because Arthur collects pressed ferns and remains silent rather than discussing practical affairs, the narrator interprets this as 'the hollow stillness of a mind that had run out of thoughts.'
This demonstrates how the narrator's utilitarian bias leads to a critical and narrow portrayal of Arthur.

Key Concept

Narrator Reliability, Perspective, and Bias
Rate this question

Topics

Narrator Reliability, Perspective, and Bias

More questions from this topic