Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumHistorical and Cultural Context

Read the following translated passage from the novel *Como agua para chocolate* (1989) by the Mexican writer Laura Esquivel:

“You know very well that, as the youngest of my daughters, it is your duty to care for me until the day of my death.” With these words, Mama Elena sealed Tita’s fate. For Tita, this family rule, which had been passed down through generations, felt like an insurmountable wall. She could not understand why she, who loved and was loved, was denied the right to build her own life simply because of her birth order.

“But Mama, it seems to me that—”

“Do not think, Tita! I have told you once and for all that you are not to marry. In this house, my word is law, and tradition is not to be questioned. If your sister Rosaura wishes to marry, that is another matter, but your path is already written.”

This conversation took place in the kitchen, the only place where Tita felt a sense of freedom. Outside, the winds of the Mexican Revolution were beginning to blow, threatening to dismantle the old estates and the rigid social hierarchies of Porfirian Mexico. Yet, inside the ranch, Mama Elena’s domestic dictatorship mirrored the authoritarianism of the regime that the revolutionaries sought to overthrow.

How does the domestic conflict between Mama Elena and Tita reflect the broader historical and cultural tensions in Mexico during the early twentieth century?

  1. A
    It reflects the immediate success of the revolutionary forces in dismantling traditional domestic roles in rural households.
  2. It represents the parallel between the authoritarian domestic rule inside the home and the oppressive political structures of the Porfirian era that the revolution sought to overthrow.Answer
  3. C
    It shows that Mama Elena's strictness is a strategic attempt to shield Tita from joining the armed rebel forces.
  4. D
    It suggests that Tita's primary motivation is to escape manual labor in the kitchen rather than to seek personal autonomy.

Answer

The domestic conflict represents the parallel between Mama Elena's authoritarian household rule and the oppressive political structures of the Porfirian era.
The conflict between Mama Elena's strict domestic rule and Tita's desire for independence mirrors the national-level clash between the authoritarian Porfiriato regime and the revolutionary movement seeking liberation and change.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the historical setting of the passage.
The passage takes place in early twentieth-century Mexico, noting that the Mexican Revolution is beginning to challenge the Porfolian-era social hierarchies.
To establish the historical context of the text.
2
Compare the domestic conflict to the national context.
Mama Elena's domestic dictatorship inside the household mirrors the national authoritarian political structures that the revolution aimed to overthrow.
To link the character's internal family conflict directly to the cultural and historical climate of the era.
3
Identify the option that correctly describes this parallel.
The option highlighting the parallel between domestic authoritarianism and Porfirian political oppression is the correct choice.
To select the response that best demonstrates an understanding of historical and cultural context.

Key Concept

Historical and Cultural Context in Literature
Rate this question

Topics

Historical and Cultural Context

More questions from this topic