Examkin

Question

Difficulty: EasyLabor Movements and Gilded Age Conflict

Read the following excerpt from a statement by Henry Clay Frick, manager of the Homestead Steel Works, in 1892:

"I will never recognize the Union, never, never! We had to decide whether we or the Amalgamated Association [of Iron and Steel Workers] should run the Homestead works."

Which of the following general trends in late nineteenth-century industrial relations is best reflected by the attitude expressed in the excerpt?

  1. The determination of industrial managers to break the power of organized labor unions and maintain control over workplace operations.Answer
  2. B
    The federal government's policy of maintaining strict neutrality in disputes between industrial workers and managers.
  3. C
    A successful political alliance between urban factory workers and rural Populists to nationalize heavy industries.
  4. D
    The voluntary dissolution of large corporations in favor of worker-owned cooperative shops.

Answer

The determination of industrial managers to break the power of organized labor unions and maintain control over workplace operations.
The quote by Henry Clay Frick illustrates the fierce resistance of Gilded Age business owners and managers to labor unions. During this period of rapid industrialization, employers actively worked to dismantle unions—such as the Amalgamated Association of Iron and Steel Workers during the Homestead Strike of 1892—to assert unilateral control over wages, working hours, and operational decisions.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the primary source quote.
The quote shows Henry Clay Frick declaring that he will never recognize the union and that management must run the Homestead works.
Understanding the source's main argument is the first step in contextualizing it within historical trends.
2
Identify the historical context of the quote.
The quote is from 1892, during the Homestead Strike, a major Gilded Age labor conflict.
Placing the source in its correct period helps connect it to broader themes of labor and industrialization.
3
Match Frick's attitude to late nineteenth-century industrial relations trends.
Frick's refusal to recognize the union and insistence on managerial control reflects the broader corporate effort to crush organized labor and retain absolute control over workplaces.
This connects the specific statement to the general historical development of Gilded Age labor conflict.

Key Concept

Industrial management's resistance to organized labor during the Gilded Age.
Rate this question

Topics

Labor Movements and Gilded Age Conflict

More questions from this topic