Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumChanging Social Hierarchies

Source: Louis de Rouvroy, Duke of Saint-Simon, *Memoirs*, describing the reign of King Louis XIV of France, late seventeenth century.

"He [the king] was well aware that though he might crush a nobleman... he could not ruin him or his line... whereas a secretary of state or other minister, taken from the common people or the lesser nobility, could be raised to the highest peak of wealth and power, and then cast down into his original insignificance by a single word... This is why he excluded all great nobles from his councils, and chose his ministers from men of low extraction or the legal profession, who owed everything to his favor."

Which of the following processes in the period 1450–1750 is best illustrated by the passage?

  1. A
    The expansion of decentralized political structures based on reciprocal feudal obligations.
  2. B
    The implementation of devshirme recruitment policies to construct a loyal bureaucratic class.
  3. The efforts of monarchs to centralize political authority by limiting the power of traditional noble elites.Answer
  4. D
    The reorganization of agricultural labor structures following the introduction of Columbian Exchange crops.

Answer

The efforts of monarchs to centralize political authority by limiting the power of traditional noble elites.
The correct answer is the option stating that monarchs sought to centralize political authority by limiting the power of traditional noble elites. The passage illustrates how King Louis XIV of France deliberately bypassed the established great nobility when choosing his ministers. By elevating men of lower extraction or from the legal profession, who owed their wealth and status entirely to the king's favor, Louis XIV successfully undermined the traditional aristocracy's capacity to challenge royal policies, thereby centralizing state authority.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the historical source to determine the main administrative reform being described.
The author notes that King Louis XIV chose to exclude great nobles from his councils in favor of ministers from the middle class or lesser nobility who were entirely dependent on his favor.
Understanding the core behavior described in the source is the first step in contextualizing the historical development.
2
Connect this administrative reform to broader historical processes in the period 1450–1750.
During the early modern era, monarchs in Europe and other regions consolidated absolute authority by creating new bureaucratic elites (such as the Nobles of the Robe in France) to bypass and weaken the traditional noble families.
This links the specific text to the learning objective concerning how the power of existing political and military elites fluctuated under challenges from centralizing rulers.
3
Evaluate the choices to find the statement that matches this political centralization process.
The statement regarding monarchs centralizing authority by limiting the power of traditional noble elites is the correct option.
This choice accurately captures the historical trend shown in the source while avoiding common conceptual errors.

Key Concept

The consolidation of political power by early modern monarchs at the expense of traditional noble hierarchies.
Rate this question

Topics

Changing Social Hierarchies

More questions from this topic