Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardChanging Social Hierarchies

"The sultan’s hall was crowded with people, among whom were many high officials... In this vast crowd there was not a single man who owed his position to anything but his own valor and merit. No distinction is attached to birth among the Turks; the deference to be paid to a man is measured by the character of his services and the deeds he has done... Those who hold the highest posts under the Sultan are very often the sons of shepherds or herdsmen, and so far from being ashamed of their birth, they make a boast of it... This is because the Turks do not believe that high qualities are hereditary."
—Ogier Ghiselin de Busbecq, Ambassador of the Holy Roman Empire to the Ottoman Court, *Turkish Letters*, c. 1581

Which of the following best explains how the recruitment system described in the passage contributed to shifts in the Ottoman Empire's social hierarchy during the period 1450–1750?

  1. A
    It successfully replicated the European feudal model of dividing regional governance among loyal lords and vassals.
  2. B
    It established a system of hereditary chattel slavery that permanently subjugated the Christian population to manual agricultural labor.
  3. It created a loyal, bureaucratized military and administrative elite that offset the power of the traditional Turkish landholding aristocracy.Answer
  4. D
    It aimed to convert the Shi'a majority of Iran into Sunni administrators to eliminate geographic border disputes with the Safavid Empire.

Answer

The correct option is the one stating that the system created a loyal, bureaucratized military and administrative elite that offset the power of the traditional Turkish landholding aristocracy.
The recruitment system described in the passage (the devshirme) allowed the Ottoman sultans to cultivate a class of administrators and soldiers (like the Janissaries and palace bureaucrats) who owed their loyalty entirely to the sultan rather than to local aristocratic families. This centralized system reduced the power of the traditional Turkish landholding aristocracy (timar holders) and transformed the empire's social hierarchy by promoting individuals based on state-defined merit rather than hereditary nobility.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the source passage written by Ogier Ghiselin de Busbecq.
The passage describes a system where individuals rise to high Ottoman offices based on merit and service rather than noble birth, noting that many high officials come from humble backgrounds.
Understanding the source context (meritocracy and social mobility in the Ottoman administration) is necessary to evaluate its impact on the social hierarchy.
2
Connect the description to the historical Ottoman system of devshirme and the Janissaries.
Identify that the Ottoman state recruited Christian youth, converted them to Islam, and educated them for state service, creating a class of loyal bureaucrats and elite soldiers.
Linking the source to the specific institutional context of Unit 4 (Changing Social Hierarchies) allows for proper historical analysis.
3
Evaluate the effects of this system on the existing social hierarchy.
The system allowed the sultan to build a loyal central administration, thereby reducing the influence of the traditional Turkish landowning nobility (aristocracy).
This direct relationship explains the political and social shift, which is the core learning objective.

Key Concept

The consolidation of imperial power and changing social hierarchies through recruitment systems (like the devshirme) that countered traditional elites.
Rate this question

Topics

Changing Social Hierarchies

More questions from this topic