Examkin

Question

Difficulty: Very hardChanging Social Hierarchies

"Since the samurai have come to reside in the castle towns, they must purchase all their daily necessities from the merchants. Because the prices of goods fluctuate and the samurai's stipends are fixed in rice, the merchants have gained control over the wealth of the land. The samurai now live in constant debt to the townspeople, pawning their armor and weapons. The merchants, though legally lower in status, live in luxury and command the deference of those who should be their rulers. If this inversion of the social order continues, the authority of the military government will surely erode."
—Ogyū Sorai, Japanese Confucian philosopher, Political Discourse (Seidan), c. 1727

Which of the following developments in Tokugawa Japan (1603–1867) best explains the social transition described in the passage?

  1. A
    The adoption of European-style feudal structures that replaced traditional merit-based bureaucratic systems.
  2. B
    The transition of the samurai class into a hereditary civil service recruited through a devshirme-style tribute system.
  3. The economic commercialization and urbanization fostered by the shogunate's political stabilization policies.Answer
  4. D
    The disruption of traditional agricultural hierarchies caused by the introduction of American crops during the Columbian Exchange.

Answer

The economic commercialization and urbanization fostered by the shogunate's political stabilization policies.
The correct answer is correct because the Tokugawa shogunate's establishment of political stability (Pax Tokugawa) and the alternative attendance system (sankin-kōtai) forced samurai to reside in castle towns, prompting the development of a highly commercialized domestic economy. Because samurai received fixed stipends in rice, they had to rely on merchants to convert their rice to cash, enabling merchants to accumulate significant wealth and shift the balance of social power.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the main argument of the source.
The passage describes a situation where merchants (townspeople), despite their low legal status, are gaining economic dominance over the samurai class, who are falling into debt.
Understanding the core argument of the historical source is necessary to connect it to broader historical developments.
2
Relate the source to the historical context of Tokugawa Japan.
The Tokugawa shogunate enforced peace, restricted the samurai to castle towns, and paid them in fixed rice stipends, while a national commercial network developed.
Placing the source in its correct historical context helps identify the underlying causes of the described social changes.
3
Connect this to the changing social hierarchy of the period.
This commercialization allowed merchants to accumulate wealth and power, challenging the traditional Confucian social hierarchy that placed them at the bottom.
This links the specific details in the passage to the broader AP World History concept of changing social hierarchies in the early modern era.
4
Evaluate the options to find the one that best explains this socio-economic shift.
The option focusing on commercialization and urbanization driven by political stabilization accurately reflects these historical dynamics.
Selecting the correct option requires identifying the one that aligns with both the source's content and accurate historical analysis.

Key Concept

Tokugawa Japan's changing social hierarchies and the rise of the merchant class due to commercialization.
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Rate this question

Topics

Changing Social Hierarchies

More questions from this topic