Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumSelect-in-Passage Question Analysis

Read the passage below:

Historians of the Venetian silk industry have long debated the primary catalyst behind the guild reforms of 1540. Traditional scholarship asserted that these regulatory shifts were direct responses to increased import tariffs imposed by rival Mediterranean powers. However, recent archival analyses of workshop ledger books reveal that internal labor shortages, caused by an outbreak of epidemic disease in the artisanal quarters, actually compelled master weavers to restructure production quotas. To mitigate the resulting loss of skilled labor, the guild leadership introduced standardized apprenticeship timelines and centralized raw material distribution. Consequently, while external trade pressures undoubtedly complicated Venetian commercial strategy, they served merely as secondary background conditions rather than the immediate driver of structural reform.

Select the sentence in the passage that presents new empirical evidence challenging a long-held explanation.

Answer: However, recent archival analyses of workshop ledger books reveal that internal labor shortages, caused by an outbreak of epidemic disease in the artisanal quarters, actually compelled master weavers to restructure production quotas. / However, recent archival analyses of workshop ledger books reveal that internal labor shortages, caused by an outbreak of epidemic disease in the artisanal quarters, actually compelled master weavers to restructure production quotas / recent archival analyses of workshop ledger books reveal that internal labor shortages, caused by an outbreak of epidemic disease in the artisanal quarters, actually compelled master weavers to restructure production quotas. / recent archival analyses of workshop ledger books reveal that internal labor shortages, caused by an outbreak of epidemic disease in the artisanal quarters, actually compelled master weavers to restructure production quotas

Answer

However, recent archival analyses of workshop ledger books reveal that internal labor shortages, caused by an outbreak of epidemic disease in the artisanal quarters, actually compelled master weavers to restructure production quotas.
The sentence beginning with 'However, recent archival analyses...' is correct because it explicitly introduces new empirical data ('archival analyses of workshop ledger books') that refutes the long-held assumption that external tariffs drove the guild reforms, demonstrating instead that internal labor shortages were the primary cause.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the prompt requirement
The target sentence must identify 'new empirical evidence' that 'challenges a long-held explanation'.
Understanding the precise rhetorical function required by the item stem is essential for selecting the correct sentence.
2
Identify the long-held explanation in the passage
The second sentence presents the traditional view that regulatory shifts were caused by import tariffs.
Establishing what the long-held view is allows us to locate where that view is contested.
3
Locate the sentence introducing new empirical findings that counter this traditional view
The third sentence introduces 'recent archival analyses of workshop ledger books' (new empirical evidence) showing that 'internal labor shortages... actually compelled master weavers to restructure production quotas' (challenging the tariff explanation).
This sentence directly fulfills both criteria: citing empirical findings (ledger analyses) and contradicting the traditional catalyst hypothesis.

Key Concept

Select-in-Passage Rhetorical Role Analysis
Estimated Time:1m 15s
Rate this question

Topics

Select-in-Passage Question Analysis

More questions from this topic