Question

Difficulty: MediumElements of Insurable Risk

Match each proposed insurance exposure with the primary element of an ideally insurable risk that it violates.

  • A homeowner seeks coverage for the gradual, expected wearing out of their roof shingles over a 25-year period.The loss must be accidental and due to chance
  • A commercial enterprise requests a policy to protect against revenue loss caused solely by a global economic depression.The loss must not be catastrophic
  • An applicant wants to insure a collection of family letters that hold immense emotional significance but no market value.The loss must be definite and measurable
  • A vehicle owner attempts to buy a policy designed solely to cover the $40 cost of routine monthly oil changes.The premium must be economically feasible

Answer

Gradual wearing out violates 'accidental and due to chance'. Global depression violates 'must not be catastrophic'. Family letters violate 'definite and measurable'. Routine oil changes violate 'economically feasible premium'.
Each proposed exposure fundamentally lacks one of the required criteria for private insurance. Wear and tear lacks fortuity (chance). Sentimental items lack measurable financial value. Depressions represent unpoolable catastrophic market risk. Routine maintenance involves administrative costs that destroy economic feasibility.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the roof shingles scenario.
Identified as inevitable wear and tear.
Insurance requires a chance of loss (accidental), not a certainty. Therefore, it violates the 'accidental and due to chance' element.
2
Analyze the economic depression scenario.
Identified as a systemic event affecting millions simultaneously.
Insurers rely on the Law of Large Numbers, which fails if a single event causes simultaneous losses for a large portion of the pool. This violates the 'must not be catastrophic' element.
3
Analyze the family letters scenario.
Identified as possessing sentimental rather than financial value.
An insurer must be able to calculate the exact financial impact of a loss. Sentimental value violates the 'definite and measurable' element.
4
Analyze the routine oil change scenario.
Identified as a low-severity, high-frequency expected maintenance cost.
Administering frequent small claims would cost the insurer significantly more than the claims themselves in overhead, requiring a premium higher than the benefit. This violates the 'economically feasible premium' element.

Key Concept

The ideal elements of an insurable risk determine whether an exposure can be safely and practically insured by a private carrier.
Rate this question