Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumElements of Insurable Risk

A manufacturing facility uses specialized industrial drill bits that, due to constant friction, are guaranteed to wear down and become useless after exactly 500 hours of operation. The business owner applies for a commercial property insurance policy specifically to pay for the replacement of these drill bits every time they wear out. Based on the fundamental elements of an ideally insurable risk, why would an underwriter reject this application?

  1. The replacement of the equipment is an inevitable certainty, whereas insurable losses must be accidental and due to chance.Answer
  2. B
    The exposure represents a speculative risk because the business owner knows exactly when the equipment will fail.
  3. C
    The deterioration of the equipment constitutes a physical hazard rather than a primary peril.
  4. D
    The business owner is attempting to utilize risk retention when this situation requires risk transfer.

Answer

The application would be rejected because the replacement of the equipment is an inevitable certainty, whereas insurable losses must be accidental and due to chance.
For a risk to be ideally insurable, the loss must be accidental, unintentional, and due to chance. In this scenario, the drill bits wearing out is a guaranteed certainty caused by normal business operations. Because the loss is inevitable, it is considered a standard maintenance expense rather than an insurable event.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the core characteristics of the risk presented in the scenario.
The deterioration of the drill bits after 500 hours is described as 'guaranteed' and 'inevitable certainty' due to constant friction.
Understanding the exact nature of the loss exposure is required to evaluate it against underwriting criteria.
2
Compare the identified characteristics against the elements of an ideally insurable risk.
One fundamental element is that a loss must be fortuitous (accidental and due to chance). The scenario violates this requirement because the loss is intentional/expected.
Insurance is meant to indemnify against unexpected financial losses, not to fund standard, predictable operational expenses.
3
Evaluate the options to find the one that accurately identifies this violated element.
The option stating that the replacement is an inevitable certainty correctly identifies the absence of the 'accidental and due to chance' element.
This directly explains the underwriter's legitimate basis for rejecting the coverage request.

Key Concept

Elements of Insurable Risk: Accidental and Due to Chance
Estimated Time:1m 15s
Rate this question

Topics

Elements of Insurable Risk

More questions from this topic