Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardThe Legislature: Unicameralism and Bicameralism

In a federal presidential constitutional democracy operating a bicameral legislature, an annual appropriation bill passed by the lower house automatically becomes law upon executive assent even if the upper house fails to deliberate on or concur with it.

Answer: Answer

Answer

False. In a federal presidential democracy with a bicameral legislature, a bill must be passed by both chambers before it can receive executive assent and become law.
The statement is false because federal presidential constitutions establishing bicameral legislatures require that both chambers consider, pass, and reconcile any legislative measure—including financial and appropriation bills—before it can receive executive assent.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the constitutional requirement for law-making in a federal bicameral presidential system.
Both the upper and lower legislative chambers hold coordinate authority in the legislative process.
Bicameralism in federal states is structured to balance population-based representation with equal state/regional representation.
2
Evaluate the effect of one chamber failing to pass or deliberate on an appropriation bill.
The legislative process stalls because a single chamber cannot unilaterally enact federal legislation.
Neither house has constitutional authority to bypass the other house and submit a unichamber-passed bill directly to the President for assent.
3
Differentiate federal presidential bicameralism from parliamentary money bill rules.
Unlike parliamentary systems with subordinate upper chambers, presidential bicameralism mandates concurrence by both houses for money bills.
Appropriation bills require approval from both houses or resolution via a constitutional joint conference committee before enactment.

Key Concept

Coordinate legislative authority of bicameral chambers in a federal presidential system
Rate this question

Topics

The Legislature: Unicameralism and Bicameralism

More questions from this topic