Question

Difficulty: HardLaws of Chemical Combination (Conservation of Mass, Definite & Multiple Proportions)

A metal XX forms two distinct chlorides. Quantitative analysis shows that in Chloride 1, 5.40 g5.40\text{ g} of XX combines with 10.65 g10.65\text{ g} of chlorine. In Chloride 2, 3.60 g3.60\text{ g} of XX combines with 10.65 g10.65\text{ g} of chlorine. If the empirical formula of Chloride 1 is XCl2XCl_2, calculate the subscript value yy in the empirical formula XClyXCl_y of Chloride 2.

Answer: 3

Answer

The value of the subscript y is 3.
Applying the Law of Multiple Proportions, when a fixed mass of chlorine (10.65 g10.65\text{ g}) reacts with different masses of metal XX (5.40 g5.40\text{ g} and 3.60 g3.60\text{ g}), the mass ratio of XX is 5.40:3.60=3:25.40 : 3.60 = 3 : 2. This implies that for a fixed amount of metal XX, the ratio of chlorine atoms in Chloride 1 to Chloride 2 is 2:32 : 3. Since Chloride 1 is XCl2XCl_2, Chloride 2 must be XCl3XCl_3, yielding y=3y = 3.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Determine the mass of chlorine per gram of metal X in Chloride 1.
10.65 g5.40 g=1.9722 g Cl/X\frac{10.65\text{ g}}{5.40\text{ g}} = 1.9722\text{ g } Cl / \text{g } X
This establishes the baseline quantitative relationship for the formula XCl2XCl_2.
2
Determine the mass of chlorine per gram of metal X in Chloride 2.
10.65 g3.60 g=2.9583 g Cl/X\frac{10.65\text{ g}}{3.60\text{ g}} = 2.9583\text{ g } Cl / \text{g } X
This determines the mass of chlorine per unit mass of metal in the second compound.
3
Calculate the simple multiple proportion ratio between the two compounds.
2.95831.9722=1.5\frac{2.9583}{1.9722} = 1.5
According to the Law of Multiple Proportions, the masses of chlorine combining with a fixed mass of X stand in a simple whole-number ratio.
4
Multiply the subscript of chlorine in the first compound by the calculated ratio.
y=2×1.5=3y = 2 \times 1.5 = 3
Since Chloride 1 has 2 chlorine atoms (XCl2XCl_2), Chloride 2 must have 2×1.5=32 \times 1.5 = 3 chlorine atoms (XCl3XCl_3).

Key Concept

Law of Multiple Proportions
Rate this question