Question

Difficulty: Very hardInferential Comprehension and Deduction

Read the passage below carefully:

In the high-altitude tea-growing region of the Mambilla Plateau, smallholder farmers historically relied on cooperative shade-tree agroforestry to regulate microclimate temperature and soil moisture. However, following the introduction of sun-tolerant clonal tea varieties, agricultural extension agents advised the systematic clearing of native canopy trees to maximize photosynthetic exposure and short-term yield. Although crude harvests initially rose significantly, the canopy removal exposed the topsoil to severe desiccation and organic matter depletion during dry seasons. Consequently, farmers cultivating the unshaded clones became dependent on costly synthetic fertilizers and micro-irrigation systems to maintain soil fertility and hydration. By 2024, smallholders who had eradicated their shade canopy suffered lower net profit margins than those maintaining partial agroforestry buffers, as the spiraling expenditure on artificial inputs surpassed the revenues generated by higher raw yield.

Statement: Based on the passage, the primary cause of reduced net profit margins among farmers adopting sun-tolerant clonal tea was an inherent failure of the crop to produce higher physical yields.

Answer: Answer

Answer

The statement is False. The passage demonstrates that physical harvests increased with sun-tolerant clonal tea, but net profit margins decreased because the cost of necessary synthetic fertilizers and micro-irrigation exceeded the financial gains from the higher yield.
The statement is false because the passage explicitly attributes the reduced net profit margins to the high operational costs of artificial inputs (fertilizers and irrigation) required after deforestation, rather than a failure of the clonal tea to produce higher physical yields.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the core claim made in the statement.
The statement asserts that lower net profit margins were caused by an inherent inability of the new crop variety to produce higher physical yields.
Identifying the specific cause-and-effect relationship proposed by the question.
2
Scan the passage for explicit evidence regarding physical crop output.
The text states that 'crude harvests initially rose significantly' and mentions 'revenues generated by higher raw yield'.
Determining whether physical yield increased or decreased after clearing the canopy.
3
Synthesize the contextual evidence explaining the actual cause of reduced profit margins.
The passage explains that canopy removal caused soil desiccation, forcing farmers to buy expensive synthetic fertilizers and micro-irrigation, which created input costs that outpaced gains from the higher yields.
Deduce the true underlying reason for the economic decline.
4
Compare the statement's claim against the deduced evidence.
Since physical yield did increase, attributing the reduced profit margin to a failure in physical output is logically contradicted by the text.
Establishing the final truth value of the statement.

Key Concept

Inferential Comprehension and Deduction
Rate this question