Examkin

Question

Difficulty: Very hardMust Be True Questions

Read the following information carefully:

All commercial banking systems that implement immediate settlement protocols require robust interbank liquidity. A banking system cannot maintain robust interbank liquidity unless it relies on overnight lending facilities or holds substantial excess reserves. Any system that relies on overnight lending facilities is vulnerable to sudden credit freezes. However, holding substantial excess reserves invariably suppresses the system's overall profitability. Furthermore, no system that is vulnerable to sudden credit freezes can attract international venture capital.

Based strictly on the information above, evaluate whether the following statement must be true: Any commercial banking system that implements immediate settlement protocols but manages to attract international venture capital must experience suppressed overall profitability.

Answer: Answer

Answer

True
The statement accurately reflects a forced deductive chain. A system with immediate settlement must have robust liquidity (requiring either overnight lending or excess reserves). By successfully attracting international venture capital, the system proves it is not vulnerable to credit freezes, meaning it cannot be relying on overnight lending. The only remaining way to satisfy the liquidity requirement is by holding excess reserves, which guarantees suppressed profitability.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Diagram the first premise relating settlement protocols and liquidity.
Immediate Settlement (IS) -> Robust Interbank Liquidity (RIL)
To establish the initial condition required for any system implementing immediate settlement protocols.
2
Diagram the 'unless' condition regarding how robust liquidity is maintained.
RIL -> Overnight Lending (OL) OR Excess Reserves (ER)
To show the only two possible pathways available once a system has robust interbank liquidity.
3
Diagram the consequences of overnight lending and excess reserves.
OL -> Vulnerable to Credit Freezes (VCF), and ER -> Suppressed Profitability (SP)
To link the two pathways to their inevitable respective outcomes as stated in the text.
4
Diagram the condition regarding international venture capital and evaluate its contrapositive.
VCF -> Cannot Attract International VC (~AIVC), which translates via contrapositive to: Attracting International VC (AIVC) -> ~VCF
To understand what can be deduced if a system successfully attracts international venture capital.
5
Chain the deductions based on the hypothetical scenario in the statement (IS and AIVC).
IS -> RIL -> (OL or ER). Since AIVC -> ~VCF, and OL -> VCF, we know ~OL. Thus, ER must be true. Since ER -> SP, SP must be true.
To definitively prove that any system meeting both conditions (IS and AIVC) is forced down the Excess Reserves pathway, necessarily resulting in Suppressed Profitability.

Key Concept

Conditional Logic Chaining and Contrapositives
Rate this question

Topics

Must Be True Questions

More questions from this topic