Question

Difficulty: MediumTracking Viewpoints

For many years, the prevailing historical narrative held that the Graeco-Arabic translation movement of the eighth to tenth centuries was born out of utilitarian necessity, driven by the Abbasid empire's need for practical administrative texts. However, recent revisionist scholars have challenged this view, arguing instead that the movement was fundamentally ideological. According to these revisionists, Abbasid caliphs sponsored translations of Greek philosophy to appropriate ancient Hellenic wisdom, thereby legitimizing their rule and intellectually undermining the rival Byzantine Empire. While this ideological framework convincingly explains the imperial sponsorship of the movement, it overlooks the micro-level social dynamics that sustained it. The sheer volume of translated works cannot be fully accounted for without recognizing the intense competition for patronage among the translators themselves, who translated increasingly esoteric treatises to secure social prestige.

Evaluate the following statement as true or false based on the passage:

The revisionist scholars mentioned in the passage argue that the sheer volume of translated works was driven primarily by the translators' competition for social prestige and patronage.

Answer: Answer

Answer

The statement is false because it misattributes the author's original critique to the revisionist scholars.
The statement is false because it commits a viewpoint misattribution error. The passage states that the revisionists focus on the 'ideological framework' of imperial sponsorship. The argument that translator competition drove the sheer volume of works is explicitly introduced by the author as a phenomenon that the revisionist perspective 'overlooks'.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the views explicitly attributed to the 'revisionist scholars'.
The revisionists argue the movement was fundamentally ideological and aimed at legitimizing Abbasid rule by appropriating Hellenic wisdom.
To establish the specific claims belonging to this group before evaluating the statement.
2
Locate the phrase regarding 'competition for patronage' and 'social prestige' in the text.
This concept appears in the final sentence of the passage.
To verify exactly who is asserting this specific claim.
3
Determine the author's stance on the revisionist view regarding this specific concept.
The author states that the revisionist ideological framework 'overlooks' these micro-level social dynamics.
To confirm that the patronage argument is the author's addition, not the revisionists' theory.

Key Concept

Tracking Viewpoints and Perspective Misattribution
Rate this question