Question

Difficulty: MediumPerspective of Mentioned Groups

For decades, the standard historical narrative regarding the mechanical clock posited it as an autonomous agent of social change. According to this view, championed by technological determinists, the introduction of the mechanical clock in fourteenth-century Europe unilaterally imposed a rigid, abstract framework of hours and minutes onto society, thereby fundamentally reshaping labor practices and daily routines. Recently, however, a group of scholars known as social-integrationists has challenged this narrative. The social-integrationists argue that the mechanical clock did not independently generate a cultural shift toward strict timekeeping; rather, it was adopted precisely because a nascent cultural demand for temporal regulation already existed. They note that the rigorous schedules of Benedictine monasteries and the complex coordination required in the Flemish textile trade necessitated precise timekeeping long before mechanical escapements were widely available. In the integrationists' view, the mechanical clock was merely a technological fulfillment of a socioeconomic order that was already crystallizing.

Based on the passage, the social-integrationists would be most likely to agree with which one of the following statements regarding the relationship between technology and society?

  1. A technological innovation typically gains widespread acceptance by serving preexisting cultural or economic demands rather than by unilaterally imposing new values.Answer
  2. B
    The introduction of novel technologies such as the mechanical clock fundamentally reshapes a society by enforcing new abstract frameworks on daily routines.
  3. C
    The widespread availability of mechanical escapements was a necessary prerequisite for the complex coordination characterizing early textile manufacturing.
  4. D
    The development of any new technology is invariably the direct result of economic necessity rather than an independent pursuit of scientific innovation.
  5. E
    Institutions requiring strict discipline, such as monasteries, are historically the sole drivers of major technological innovations.

Answer

The social-integrationists would most likely agree that a technological innovation typically gains widespread acceptance by serving preexisting cultural or economic demands rather than by unilaterally imposing new values.
The passage explicitly defines the social-integrationists' position: they believe the mechanical clock was adopted 'precisely because a nascent cultural demand for temporal regulation already existed.' They see the technology as a 'fulfillment of a socioeconomic order that was already crystallizing,' acting as a response to societal needs rather than an independent creator of new values. The correct answer perfectly captures this dynamic, applying it as a general statement regarding technology and society.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Locate the specific group mentioned in the question stem ('social-integrationists') within the passage text.
Found in the latter half of the passage, where their views are contrasted against 'technological determinists.'
Accurate viewpoint attribution requires isolating the claims explicitly tied to the target group.
2
Analyze the core argument and specific claims made by the social-integrationists.
They argue the clock did not generate the cultural shift toward timekeeping but was adopted because 'a nascent cultural demand... already existed.' They view technology as a 'fulfillment of a socioeconomic order that was already crystallizing.'
Understanding the logic underlying their specific historical claim allows for generalization to broader principles.
3
Evaluate the answer choices to find the one that logically aligns with this generalized perspective.
The correct option correctly abstracts the group's specific argument about the mechanical clock into a general principle: technology succeeds by serving existing demands, not by independently imposing new ones.
LSAT inference questions often require extrapolating a specific argument to a broader, logically consistent claim.

Key Concept

Identifying and extrapolating the underlying assumptions of a specific group cited in a passage, while distinguishing their perspective from opposing views.
Rate this question