Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumComparative Analogies

Consider the following two excerpts outlining distinct analytical models:

Excerpt A (Economics)
A nation's baseline monetary policy establishes the general environment for economic expansion, yet the unpredictable swings in collective consumer sentiment ultimately drive short-term market volatility.

Excerpt B (Epidemiology)
The inherent transmissibility of a pathogen sets the foundational risk level for widespread infection, whereas stochastic, high-contact superspreader events directly precipitate localized outbreak spikes.

Based on the analogical relationship between the two models, match each economic component from Excerpt A with its precise functional analog in Excerpt B.

  • Baseline monetary policyInherent transmissibility of a pathogen
  • General environment for economic expansionFoundational risk level for widespread infection
  • Unpredictable swings in collective consumer sentimentStochastic, high-contact superspreader events
  • Short-term market volatilityLocalized outbreak spikes

Answer

Baseline monetary policy matches inherent transmissibility; general environment matches foundational risk level; unpredictable consumer sentiment swings matches stochastic superspreader events; short-term market volatility matches localized outbreak spikes.
The correct pairings align the foundational causes (monetary policy and pathogen transmissibility), their corresponding systemic conditions (economic expansion environment and infection risk level), the unpredictable catalysts (consumer sentiment swings and superspreader events), and the resulting acute effects (market volatility and outbreak spikes). This mapping perfectly preserves the causal architecture of both excerpts.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the causal and logical structure of Excerpt A.
Identified a foundational factor (monetary policy) leading to a broad condition (economic environment), contrasted with a volatile catalyst (consumer sentiment) leading to an acute effect (market volatility).
Understanding the precise role of each element is necessary to map them across disciplines.
2
Analyze the causal and logical structure of Excerpt B.
Identified a foundational factor (transmissibility) leading to a broad condition (foundational risk), contrasted with a volatile catalyst (superspreader events) leading to an acute effect (localized spikes).
This establishes the parallel relational framework needed for the comparative analogy.
3
Map the corresponding elements based solely on their structural functions.
The fundamental causes match, their broad effects match, the volatile triggers match, and their acute effects match.
Comparative analogies require mapping based on functional roles within an argument rather than topical similarity or abstractness.

Key Concept

Structural Parallelism in Comparative Analogies
Rate this question

Topics

Comparative Analogies

More questions from this topic