Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumStatement and Assumptions

Consider the following policy initiative and evaluate which of the provided assumptions are logically implicit within it.

Statement: The State Agriculture Department has announced a new initiative providing a 75% subsidy on equipment costs for farmers who transition from traditional flood irrigation to drip irrigation systems.

Which of the following assumptions are implicit in the given statement? (Select all that apply)

  1. Providing financial incentives will encourage at least a portion of the farming community to adopt the new irrigation technology.Answer
  2. Drip irrigation systems possess operational benefits or water efficiencies that make them preferable to traditional flood irrigation.Answer
  3. C
    Drip irrigation is currently the most widely used agricultural method in developed nations.
  4. D
    The government will eventually impose a complete ban on traditional flood irrigation for all crops.

Answer

The implicit assumptions are that financial incentives will encourage adoption, and that drip irrigation offers preferable benefits over traditional methods.
The correct selections represent the foundational beliefs necessary for the policy to exist. For the government to offer a subsidy for drip irrigation, it must inherently believe that the subsidy will work to motivate farmers and that drip irrigation is a preferable method worth funding.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the core premise of the given statement.
The statement outlines a government policy offering a 75% subsidy to incentivize a shift from flood to drip irrigation.
Understanding the administrative action and its goal is the first step in identifying underlying assumptions.
2
Evaluate the candidate assumption regarding financial incentives.
The assumption is logically valid. The policy exists to drive a transition, implying the government believes the subsidy will successfully motivate farmers.
A proposed solution inherently assumes its own potential efficacy.
3
Evaluate the candidate assumption regarding the benefits of drip irrigation.
The assumption is valid. Promoting a transition to a new system implies the new system is recognized as superior or more efficient.
Governments do not sponsor transitions to alternative methods unless the alternative is deemed advantageous.
4
Evaluate the remaining candidate options for logical fallacies.
The options regarding developed nations (external fact) and future bans (future inference) are rejected.
Implicit assumptions must be foundational to the statement itself, avoiding outside knowledge or unstated future consequences.

Key Concept

Identifying Implicit Premises in Administrative Statements
Rate this question

Topics

Statement and Assumptions

More questions from this topic