Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumCourse of Action

Statement: A major international seaport is experiencing severe cargo container congestion due to an unexpected customs clearance software outage, resulting in dozens of cargo vessels queuing offshore and delaying critical shipments of temperature-sensitive medical supplies.

Proposed Courses of Action:
I. The port administration should immediately implement a manual paper-based clearance protocol targeted specifically at priority medical and perishable goods to bypass the software outage.
II. The government should permanently revoke the operating licenses of all shipping lines whose vessels are currently waiting offshore until the backlog is cleared.

Which of the proposed courses of action logically follow(s) from the statement?

  1. Only course of action I followsAnswer
  2. B
    Only course of action II follows
  3. C
    Neither course of action I nor II follows
  4. D
    Both courses of action I and II follow

Answer

Only course of action I follows
The decision to deploy a targeted manual clearance protocol for critical medical supplies directly addresses the immediate threat to public health caused by the software outage. It is a proportionate, constructive, and feasible step that reduces crisis impact without creating secondary administrative problems.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the core problem in the statement
Identified that a customs software failure is delaying crucial temperature-sensitive medical supplies at a major seaport.
Understanding the cause and urgency of the problem is necessary to evaluate potential administrative remedies.
2
Evaluate Course of Action I
Course of Action I is practical, feasible, directly addresses the urgency of offloading medical supplies, and acts as an effective short-term relief mechanism.
Valid courses of action must directly reduce the severity of the problem without creating unmanageable secondary issues.
3
Evaluate Course of Action II
Course of Action II unfairly targets shipping companies for an internal customs system outage and creates severe economic disruption.
Punitive administrative measures must be proportionate, lawful, and directed at the actual responsible parties.

Key Concept

Evaluating Administrative Feasibility and Proportionality in Crisis Response
Rate this question

Topics

Course of Action

More questions from this topic