Question

Difficulty: MediumGastrointestinal and Abdominal Surgery

Match each clinical presentation of anorectal disease with the most appropriate definitive surgical or procedural management.

  • A 35-year-old man with severe, tearing pain during defecation and a visible sentinel skin tag; symptoms have persisted for 8 weeks despite sitz baths and topical nifedipine.Lateral internal sphincterotomy
  • A 42-year-old woman with Crohn disease who presents with a chronically draining perineal opening that traverses a significant portion of the external anal sphincter.Placement of a draining non-cutting seton
  • A 28-year-old man with a 3-day history of severe, constant, throbbing perianal pain and a tender, fluctuant, erythematous mass near the anal verge.Immediate incision and drainage
  • A 55-year-old man with painless bright red blood per rectum and anal tissue that prolapses during bowel movements, which he must manually reduce.Rubber band ligation or excisional hemorrhoidectomy

Answer

Refractory anal fissure matches with lateral internal sphincterotomy; complex Crohn fistula matches with seton placement; perianal abscess matches with incision and drainage; Grade III internal hemorrhoids matches with rubber band ligation/excision.
Each selected surgical procedure directly addresses the underlying pathophysiology of the specific anorectal condition while minimizing severe complications (e.g., preserving sphincter tone in complex fistulas by avoiding fistulotomy).

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the first presentation (tearing pain, sentinel tag, failed medical therapy).
Identify as a chronic refractory anal fissure.
Topical agents have failed; definitive therapy is required to break the cycle of internal sphincter spasm.
2
Analyze the second presentation (draining tract traversing the external sphincter in a Crohn disease patient).
Identify as a complex fistula-in-ano.
Cutting the sphincter in a Crohn patient carries an unacceptably high risk of incontinence, making seton placement the standard of care.
3
Analyze the third presentation (throbbing pain, fluctuant mass).
Identify as an acute perianal abscess.
Abscesses represent a localized collection of purulence requiring source control via immediate drainage.
4
Analyze the fourth presentation (painless bleeding, prolapse requiring manual reduction).
Identify as Grade III internal hemorrhoids.
Grade III hemorrhoids often fail conservative measures (fiber, water) and require procedural intervention.

Key Concept

Surgical indications and procedural selection for common anorectal disorders
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Rate this question