Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumAdvance Directives and Surrogate Decision Making

A 59-year-old man is hospitalized with a severe traumatic brain injury following a high-speed motorcycle collision. He is comatose, ventilator-dependent, and lacks decision-making capacity. The trauma team recommends an open reduction and internal fixation of a complex pelvic fracture to stabilize the pelvis and prevent long-term functional morbidity. The patient is divorced and has no written advance directives. His live-in girlfriend of five years arrives and presents a legally executed 'General Durable Power of Attorney for Financial Affairs' naming her as the principal agent. She insists the surgery be performed. Shortly after, the medical team contacts the patient's 35-year-old daughter, who lives in another state. The daughter states, 'My dad told me clearly last year that he would never want any major surgeries to keep him alive if his brain was severely and permanently damaged,' and she refuses consent for the procedure. Which of the following is the most appropriate action regarding the patient's care?

  1. A
    Proceed with the surgery as requested by the girlfriend because her legal document grants medical decision-making authority.
  2. Withhold the surgery as directed by the daughter because she holds higher priority in the statutory surrogate hierarchy.Answer
  3. C
    Proceed with the surgery under the doctrine of implied consent to prevent long-term functional morbidity.
  4. D
    Schedule the surgery and consult the hospital ethics committee to transfer surrogate authority to the live-in girlfriend.
  5. E
    Postpone decision-making and require the daughter to obtain court-appointed legal guardianship to formalize her authority.

Answer

Withhold the surgery as directed by the daughter because she holds higher priority in the statutory surrogate hierarchy.
The correct answer identifies that the daughter has legal authority to make medical decisions. When an adult patient lacks decision-making capacity and has no designated healthcare proxy (Durable Power of Attorney for Healthcare), physicians must identify a surrogate decision-maker according to the state's statutory hierarchy. The standard priority order is: spouse, adult children, parents, adult siblings, and then other relatives. Unmarried partners without formal healthcare proxy designation do not typically have priority. In this scenario, the adult daughter holds statutory authority. The girlfriend's General Durable Power of Attorney for Financial Affairs only grants her authority over the patient's estate and finances, not his medical care. The closeness of the relationship or living situation does not legally override the statutory hierarchy. Therefore, the physician must follow the directive of the daughter, who is properly acting under the standard of substituted judgment by expressing what her father would have wanted.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Assess the patient's clinical capacity and the presence of any advance directives.
The patient lacks capacity and has no living will or durable power of attorney for healthcare.
Establishing capacity and reviewing legal documents is the mandatory first step in determining who can make medical decisions.
2
Evaluate the legal validity of the girlfriend's document for healthcare decisions.
The girlfriend possesses a financial power of attorney, which does not grant healthcare decision-making authority.
A financial proxy cannot direct medical decisions; a specific durable power of attorney for healthcare is required.
3
Apply the standard statutory surrogate hierarchy.
The hierarchy typically prioritizes spouses, then adult children, followed by parents, and then adult siblings. Unmarried partners generally fall lower or are not recognized unless designated formally.
When no healthcare proxy is designated, state law dictates the order of priority for surrogate decision-makers.
4
Determine the highest-ranking authorized surrogate.
The daughter (adult child) holds legal priority over the live-in girlfriend, granting the daughter sole authority to direct care based on the patient's previously expressed wishes (substituted judgment).
Physical proximity or relationship duration does not override the legal priority established by the state's statutory hierarchy.

Key Concept

In the absence of a designated healthcare proxy, medical decisions for incapacitated patients follow a strict statutory surrogate hierarchy (Spouse > Adult Children > Parents > Adult Siblings), and a financial power of attorney does not confer medical decision-making rights.
Rate this question

Topics

Advance Directives and Surrogate Decision Making

More questions from this topic