Examkin

Soru

Zorluk: OrtaBridging Gap (Supporter) Assumptions

Sociologist: Only societies that possess a formalized system of property rights are capable of developing a complex market economy. Nomadic cultures inherently lack a formalized system of property rights, as their traditional lifestyle prevents them from claiming permanent ownership of specific land tracts. Therefore, it is impossible for nomadic cultures to cultivate highly specialized artisan classes.

The sociologist's argument relies on assuming which one of the following?

  1. A
    Highly specialized artisan classes typically emerge only after a culture has established permanent, settled agricultural communities.
  2. B
    A complex market economy is the only condition necessary for a society to develop highly specialized artisan classes.
  3. The cultivation of highly specialized artisan classes requires a complex market economy.Cevap
  4. D
    Societies that do not claim permanent ownership of specific land tracts generally prioritize basic survival skills over artisan trades.
  5. E
    Any society that possesses a formalized system of property rights is capable of cultivating highly specialized artisan classes.

Cevap

The cultivation of highly specialized artisan classes requires a complex market economy.
The argument's premises establish a chain: nomadic cultures lack property rights, and without property rights, there can be no complex market economy. The conclusion then states that nomadic cultures cannot have highly specialized artisan classes. For this conclusion to logically follow, there must be a rule connecting the lack of a market economy to the lack of artisans. The correct answer provides this exact bridge by establishing that a complex market economy is a necessary prerequisite for cultivating highly specialized artisan classes. Applying the Negation Test confirms this: if artisan classes do NOT require a complex market economy, the fact that nomads lack such an economy is irrelevant, and the conclusion collapses.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Identify the core premises and the logical chain they create.
The premises establish that nomadic cultures lack formalized property rights, and without property rights, a society cannot develop a complex market economy.
Understanding the established facts is required before finding the gap in the reasoning.
2
Identify the main conclusion.
The conclusion claims that nomadic cultures cannot cultivate highly specialized artisan classes.
The conclusion introduces the target concept that must be proven by the premises.
3
Spot the 'rogue' element (the conceptual gap) between the premises and the conclusion.
The premises prove nomads lack a 'complex market economy', but the conclusion suddenly makes a claim about lacking 'highly specialized artisan classes'.
A valid logical deduction requires all terms in the conclusion to be firmly supported by the premises.
4
Formulate the necessary bridging assumption (the Supporter).
We must connect the absence of a market economy to the absence of artisans. Thus, we must assume that having artisans requires having a market economy.
Connecting the rogue conclusion element to the established premise chain logically completes the argument.

Anahtar Kavram

Bridging Gap (Supporter) Assumptions
Bu soruyu puanla

Konular

Bridging Gap (Supporter) Assumptions

Bu konudan daha fazla soru