Soru

Zorluk: OrtaIdentifying Main Conclusions

For decades, marine biologists have maintained that unihemispheric sleep—resting one half of the brain at a time—is an absolute requirement for all cetaceans to avoid drowning. It is true that this unique sleep pattern allows species like dolphins to continuously maintain the motor control needed to surface for air. The necessity of unihemispheric sleep for marine mammal survival has, nevertheless, been fundamentally overstated. Recent field observations of sperm whales demonstrate that they regularly engage in periods of profound, bihemispheric sleep. The ability of these whales to safely suspend respiration and motor function during deep, total rest proves that other physiological adaptations can adequately compensate for the absence of constant conscious awareness.

Which one of the following most accurately expresses the main conclusion of the argument?

  1. A
    Cetaceans possess alternative physiological adaptations that can compensate for the temporary loss of conscious awareness during rest.
  2. The claim that marine mammals absolutely require unihemispheric sleep to survive is significantly exaggerated.Cevap
  3. C
    The unique sleep pattern of resting one hemisphere of the brain at a time is an essential mechanism for cetaceans to avoid drowning.
  4. D
    Field observations indicate that certain large whales are capable of engaging in profound, total-brain sleep.
  5. E
    Marine mammal species that currently rely on unihemispheric sleep will gradually develop the ability to safely suspend respiration during total rest.

Cevap

The claim that marine mammals absolutely require unihemispheric sleep to survive is significantly exaggerated.
The correct answer accurately paraphrases the sentence 'The necessity of unihemispheric sleep for marine mammal survival has, nevertheless, been fundamentally overstated.' This is the ultimate point the author is trying to prove using the evidence about sperm whales.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Identify the primary topic and the different viewpoints presented in the stimulus.
The stimulus discusses the necessity of unihemispheric sleep in marine mammals, contrasting a traditional view with recent evidence.
Understanding the context is essential for breaking down the argument's structure.
2
Isolate the structural components of the argument, distinguishing between background, premises, and conclusions.
Background: Biologists say unihemispheric sleep is required. Premise: It helps dolphins surface. Claim: Its necessity is overstated. Premise: Sperm whales engage in bihemispheric sleep. Intermediate Conclusion: This proves other adaptations can compensate.
Separating these components reveals the logical flow and hierarchy of the statements.
3
Determine which conclusion is the ultimate point the author is trying to prove.
The intermediate conclusion about alternative adaptations is used to prove the broader claim that the necessity of unihemispheric sleep has been overstated. Therefore, the latter is the main conclusion.
The main conclusion must be supported by the other statements and must not support any other statement in the argument.

Anahtar Kavram

Identifying the main conclusion by analyzing the structural relationship between premises, intermediate conclusions, and the ultimate claim.
Bu soruyu puanla