Soru

Zorluk: OrtaInference and Logical Deduction

Read the following passage carefully:

Under the Municipal Urban Wetland Conservation Directive, real estate developers proposing projects within two kilometers of designated ecologically sensitive wetlands must submit an Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) to the State Pollution Control Board. If the EIA indicates a potential disruption to local hydrology, the developer is required to construct artificial buffer ponds that capture at least seventy percent of surface runoff. However, projects that incorporate rainwater harvesting systems covering at least forty percent of the total plot area are granted an explicit exemption from constructing these buffer ponds, provided their runoff volume does not exceed baseline pre-development levels. Additionally, municipal authorities are prohibited from issuing final occupancy certificates to any exempted project until an independent hydrological audit confirms that the runoff criteria have been fully satisfied. The directive does not apply to public infrastructure projects undertaken directly by state departments.

Based on the passage above, evaluate the following statement:

A private real estate developer whose project is located one kilometer from a designated wetland will automatically qualify for an exemption from constructing buffer ponds solely by installing a rainwater harvesting system across fifty percent of the plot area, regardless of post-development runoff volume.

Cevap: Cevap

Cevap

The statement is False.
The statement is False because the directive explicitly specifies that rainwater harvesting coverage grants an exemption only on the condition that post-development runoff volume remains at or below baseline pre-development levels. Satisfying the surface area threshold alone does not guarantee an exemption if the runoff restriction is ignored.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Identify the mandatory conditions for obtaining a buffer pond exemption described in the text.
The passage specifies two mandatory conditions: incorporating a rainwater harvesting system over at least forty percent of the plot area AND ensuring surface runoff volume does not exceed baseline pre-development levels.
Determining all necessary criteria stated in the directive is essential to test the claim.
2
Analyze the claim in the statement against the text's requirements.
The statement claims that fifty percent coverage grants an automatic exemption 'regardless of post-development runoff volume'.
Evaluating whether one condition alone is sufficient while ignoring a stated prerequisite.
3
Deduce the logical truth value of the statement.
Since the passage explicitly requires that runoff volume must not exceed baseline levels, ignoring this constraint invalidates the claim.
A deduction that contradicts explicit conditional limits in the source text is false.

Anahtar Kavram

Conditional Logic and Qualified Premises
Bu soruyu puanla