Question

Difficulty: HardEvaluating Relevance for Adding or Deleting Content

In 1856, eighteen-year-old chemist William Henry Perkin was attempting to synthesize quinine, a treatment for malaria, in his home laboratory. His experiments did not produce quinine; instead, they yielded a dark, sticky sludge. Perkin noticed that this sludge left a vibrant purple residue on the glass of his beaker. Purple has historically been associated with royalty due to the rarity of natural purple dyes. By diluting the residue with alcohol, Perkin isolated a substance he named mauveine, which became the world’s first synthetic organic dye.

The writer is considering deleting the underlined sentence. Should the sentence be kept or deleted?

  1. A
    Kept, because it explains the historical significance of purple dye, which helps explain why Perkin wanted to isolate the color.
  2. B
    Kept, because it establishes a contrast between the synthetic dye Perkin created and the expensive natural dyes historically favored by royalty.
  3. Deleted, because it interrupts the narrative of Perkin's experimental process with tangential information about the cultural history of the color purple.Answer
  4. D
    Deleted, because it contradicts the paragraph's earlier assertion that Perkin's primary goal was to synthesize a treatment for malaria.

Answer

The sentence should be deleted because it interrupts the narrative of Perkin's experimental process with tangential information about the cultural history of the color purple.
The option proposing that the sentence be deleted because it interrupts the narrative is correct because the paragraph focuses on the step-by-step laboratory process of Perkin's accidental discovery of mauveine. The historical detail about purple's association with royalty is a digression that interrupts this narrative flow.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the main focus of the paragraph.
The paragraph details the chronological steps of William Henry Perkin's accidental discovery of the first synthetic dye, mauveine, during an attempt to synthesize quinine.
To establish the thematic context needed to evaluate the relevance of the underlined sentence.
2
Examine the function of the underlined sentence.
The underlined sentence introduces the historical association of the color purple with royalty.
To determine whether this information directly supports the narrative of a laboratory experiment.
3
Evaluate the sentence's relevance and choose the correct option.
Since the sentence is a cultural digression that breaks the chronological flow of the laboratory discovery, it should be deleted. The option stating that it should be deleted because it interrupts the narrative of Perkin's process is correct.
To align the rhetorical decision with the correct choice.

Key Concept

Evaluating Relevance for Adding or Deleting Content
Estimated Time:1m 0s
Rate this question