Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardAdvance Directives and Surrogate Decision Making

A 52-year-old woman is admitted to the intensive care unit following a prolonged out-of-hospital cardiac arrest. She remains comatose, intubated, and unresponsive. The neurology team determines she has suffered a severe anoxic brain injury and lacks medical decision-making capacity. A review of her medical records reveals no advance directives, and she has never formally designated a healthcare proxy. Several family members are present in the waiting room and have conflicting opinions regarding the continuation of mechanical ventilation. The clinical team must identify the legally appropriate surrogate decision-maker. Arrange the following individuals in the correct order of priority (from highest priority to lowest priority) to act as the patient's surrogate decision-maker according to the standard U.S. statutory hierarchy.

  1. 1The patient's legally married husband, from whom she has been informally separated for three months
  2. 2The patient's 25-year-old biological daughter from a previous relationship
  3. 3The patient's 65-year-old mother
  4. 4The patient's 40-year-old brother, who holds the patient's financial power of attorney

Answer

The correct sequence of surrogate decision-makers, from highest to lowest priority, is: 1) the legally married husband, 2) the adult daughter, 3) the mother, and 4) the brother.
The correct order follows the standard statutory surrogate hierarchy used in most U.S. jurisdictions when a patient lacks capacity and has no designated healthcare proxy. This hierarchy legally prioritizes the spouse first (despite informal separation), followed by adult children, parents, and finally adult siblings. The brother's status as a financial power of attorney is a distractor and gives him no medical decision-making authority.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the patient's capacity and the presence of advance directives.
The patient lacks capacity and has no designated healthcare proxy or living will.
This establishes that the standard legal statutory surrogate hierarchy must be used to determine the decision-maker.
2
Evaluate the husband's legal standing.
The husband is placed first in the hierarchy.
A legally married spouse is universally the highest-priority surrogate. Informal separation does not void this legal authority; only a formal legal separation or divorce does.
3
Evaluate the adult daughter's legal standing.
The adult daughter is placed second in the hierarchy.
Adult children are next in line after the spouse in the statutory hierarchy.
4
Evaluate the mother's legal standing.
The mother is placed third in the hierarchy.
Parents have priority immediately following adult children.
5
Evaluate the brother's legal standing and his role as financial power of attorney.
The brother is placed fourth in the hierarchy.
Adult siblings follow parents. Holding a financial power of attorney grants no authority over healthcare decisions and does not elevate his status in the medical surrogate hierarchy.

Key Concept

In the absence of a designated healthcare proxy, the standard U.S. statutory surrogate hierarchy for medical decision-making is: spouse, adult children, parents, and then adult siblings. A financial power of attorney provides no authority for medical decisions.
Rate this question

Topics

Advance Directives and Surrogate Decision Making

More questions from this topic