Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumAdvance Directives and Surrogate Decision Making

A 67-year-old woman is brought to the emergency department after suffering a massive intracranial hemorrhage. She is comatose, requires mechanical ventilation, and completely lacks medical decision-making capacity. The clinical team needs consent for an urgent neurosurgical intervention. A review of her electronic health record reveals she has no written advance directive and has never legally designated a healthcare proxy. Several individuals arrive at the hospital, each expressing a desire to direct her medical care. According to the standard statutory surrogate hierarchy, arrange the following individuals in the correct order of legal priority to act as the primary surrogate decision-maker, from highest priority (first) to lowest priority (last).

  1. 1Her legally married husband of 40 years
  2. 2Her 42-year-old biological daughter
  3. 3Her 88-year-old mother
  4. 4Her 65-year-old brother
  5. 5Her 67-year-old close friend and neighbor

Answer

The correct priority order is: husband (highest priority), followed sequentially by the adult daughter, mother, brother, and finally the close friend (lowest priority).
The standard legal statutory hierarchy for surrogate decision-making prioritizes family members based on presumed closeness and knowledge of the patient's values. The broad legal consensus for priority is: 1) Spouse or domestic partner, 2) Adult children, 3) Parents, 4) Adult siblings, and 5) Other relatives or close friends. Therefore, the husband has primary decision-making authority, followed sequentially by the daughter, mother, brother, and friend.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Assess the patient's capacity and check for appointed proxies.
The patient lacks capacity and has no legally designated healthcare proxy or advance directive.
A designated proxy (Durable Power of Attorney for Healthcare) or living will would explicitly supersede the default statutory hierarchy.
2
Apply the standard state statutory surrogate hierarchy to the available individuals.
Identify the exact relationship of each individual to the patient to determine their legal rank.
When no proxy is formally appointed, state laws dictate a specific order of individuals authorized to make medical decisions based on presumed knowledge of the patient's wishes.
3
Sequence the individuals from highest to lowest legal priority.
The order is Spouse > Adult Child > Parent > Adult Sibling > Close Friend.
This sequence reflects the ethical and legal consensus, assigning priority to those traditionally considered closest to the patient.

Key Concept

In the absence of a designated healthcare proxy or an applicable advance directive, medical decisions for an incapacitated patient are made by a surrogate determined by a state-specific statutory hierarchy. The standard order is: spouse, adult children, parents, adult siblings, and finally other relatives or close friends.
Rate this question

Topics

Advance Directives and Surrogate Decision Making

More questions from this topic