Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumAdvance Directives and Surrogate Decision Making

A 55-year-old man is in the cardiac intensive care unit following a prolonged cardiac arrest. He has severe anoxic brain injury and lacks medical decision-making capacity. The clinical team needs to discuss goals of care and a potential transition to comfort-focused measures. The patient does not have a written advance directive or a designated healthcare proxy (durable power of attorney for healthcare). The hospital social worker has contacted several family members who have all arrived at the hospital and are willing to participate in decision-making.

According to the standard statutory surrogate hierarchy across most U.S. jurisdictions, arrange the following family members in the correct order of legal priority to act as the primary surrogate decision-maker, from highest priority (first) to lowest priority (last).

  1. 1His 52-year-old legally married wife
  2. 2His 30-year-old daughter
  3. 3His 78-year-old mother
  4. 4His 48-year-old brother

Answer

The correct order of legal priority is: Wife (Spouse), Daughter (Adult Child), Mother (Parent), and Brother (Adult Sibling).
When a patient lacks medical decision-making capacity and has not explicitly appointed a healthcare proxy, physicians must turn to a default surrogate decision-maker. While minor state-by-state variations exist, the standard legal order of priority across most U.S. jurisdictions follows this sequence: 1) legally married spouse, 2) adult children, 3) parents, and 4) adult siblings. Therefore, the legally married wife has the absolute highest priority. If she were unavailable, the right would pass to the adult daughter. If the daughter were unavailable, the mother would hold the next level of priority, followed finally by the adult brother.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Determine the patient's decision-making capacity and the presence of any advance directives.
The patient lacks capacity and has no designated healthcare proxy or written advance directive.
This establishes the legal necessity to rely on a default surrogate decision-maker determined by state law.
2
Identify the standard statutory hierarchy for default surrogate decision-makers.
The widely accepted framework (e.g., Uniform Health-Care Decisions Act) prioritizes family members in a specific order: spouse, adult children, parents, then adult siblings.
When no proxy is explicitly appointed by the patient, state laws dictate who has the legal authority to make medical decisions to prevent conflicts.
3
Map the available family members in the clinical vignette to the legal hierarchy.
Wife = Spouse; Daughter = Adult Child; Mother = Parent; Brother = Adult Sibling.
This translates the generic legal categories to the specific individuals involved in the case.
4
Sequence the family members from highest to lowest priority.
Wife -> Daughter -> Mother -> Brother.
This satisfies the requirement to arrange the surrogate decision-makers in the correct legally defined order.

Key Concept

In the absence of a designated healthcare proxy, surrogate medical decision-making follows a standard statutory hierarchy: Spouse, Adult Children, Parents, Adult Siblings.
Estimated Time:1m 0s
Rate this question

Topics

Advance Directives and Surrogate Decision Making

More questions from this topic